Reviews

The animal toolkit: How animal use tools by Steve Jenkins and Robin Page

cover image

Until 1960, when Jane Goodall observed a chimpanzee using a blade of grass to 'fish' for termites, it was believed that humans were the only animal to use tools and that the use of these because we have opposable thumbs were what separated us from animals in general. However, since her discovery, we've learned that many creatures use sticks, leaves, rocks, and other natural items as tools to perform all kinds of tasks.

In this fascinating picture book from Caldecott Honor-winning team Steve Jenkins and Robin Page, readers learn all about what makes a tool a tool - 'an object than an animal manipulates and uses to affect its environment, another animal or itself' - and the remarkable ways animals that use them to interact with the world. From the tailorbird, which repurposes spider silk to stitch a leaf into its nest, to the gorilla, which uses sticks to test water depth and build bridges, these animals are intelligent, innovative, and creative.

Written in a narrative style that is easily accessible to the young independent reader, and using his signature cut paper illustrations, Steve Jenkins offers readers a closer look at these animals, their habitats, and their behaviours, making it a 'poster-child' for why we must continue to offer our students a robust non fiction print collection. How else will they discover that apes and monkeys regularly clean their teeth, that crows indulge in sword-fighting just for fun and the bottlenose dolphins of Shark Bay, WA have learned to use seashells to catch food?

This is one that will fascinate animal enthusiasts and aspiring inventors everywhere, and perhaps inspire them to look more closely and investigate further.

Themes Animals - Habits, Tools.

Barbara Braxton

Bears don't cry! by Emma Chichester Clark

cover image

George is no ordinary bear. He lives with a little girl called Clementine and her mother, who have taught him to read! There was nothing he liked more than to sit in the garden and read once he'd helped out around the house because, next to reading, being useful was his favourite thing to do.

One day, when George finishes his book early and knows it will be a long time before Clementine and her mother return home, he decides to go to the library by himself. At first it's exciting to stroll along the sunny street. But poor George's trip soon ends in disaster because not everyone can cope with seeing a large brown bear walking down the street, and, to make things worse, his library book is ruined. Do bears really cry? Can anyone help George to feel better when his feelings are hurt?

This is a heart-warming story for young readers who probably wouldn't blink if they saw a bear walking down the street and they certainly wouldn't carry on like the townspeople. But it is also a timely reminder that some of the things that we say and do can hurt other's feelings, even if that is not our intention, and so we need to think before we speak or act and be sensitive to the feelings of those around us. For little ones who are so egocentric this is something they have to learn and so this, apart from being just a grand read-together, is a great discussion starter.

Themes Bears, Emotions, Friendship, Towns, Loyalty.

Barbara Braxton

Down in the dumps (series) by Wes Hargis

cover image

Down in the Westerfield Dump amongst all the rubbish discarded by the local community live Nana the dried up banana, Ms Kettle the teapot and Moreland, the crusty blob of goo. And they are the best of friends. Not for them the familiar meaning of being 'down in the dumps' - they are very happy to be who they are, where they are, doing what they do.

This is a new series for young readers who are just beginning to transition from structured basal readers to the world of novels. Almost like a graphic novel, they are specifically written for this cohort with minimal narration (clearly set in text boxes) and the action is carried in the illustrations and speech-bubble conversations. Chapters are short and fast-paced and at the end of each, readers are given direct encouragement to keep reading.

Despite a landfill area being an unlikely setting and the characters being somewhat different to what we expect, nevertheless they are very relatable with the common themes of friendship, acceptance, loyalty and fighting for what's right (even if you're trash) as they face issues that will spark consideration and conversation with suggestions for thinking, feeling and acting offered in the 'super Stinky Games' section.

Years ago, writers like Paul Jennings, Christopher Milne, Morris Gleitzman and Andy Griffiths tapped into the young readers' love for characters and plots that would make adults blush or cringe, and this does a similar thing. There's something appealing about that which doesn't appeal to grownups, and with four in this series planned, at least, this is one for even the most reluctant reader.

Barbara Braxton

The bell of the world by Gregory Day

cover image

Music, art and poetry combine in this unique ode to the natural world. Sarah is a young poet, a little lost in the world, who gradually finds solace in the restorative environment of Ngangahook, an isolated bush property owned by her beloved uncle Ferny, a kindred soul in his love of words, sounds, and beautiful natural surroundings.

Ferny has a book he carries everywhere, Furphy’s ‘Such is life’, a classic Australian novel he loves to read aloud about life on a remote cattle station in colonial Victoria. When he seeks to have his damaged volume rebound, he is astounded to discover that the binder has interwoven chapters from Moby Dick, a story of whales in the isolated expanse of the sea. Shock and surprise lead to a fresh appreciation of the worlds envisaged by the two unrelated authors.

Sarah’s curiosity and thirst for natural sounds leads her to place leaves, twigs, and other objects between the strings of the grand piano to create new strange musical compositions. Local audiences are perturbed but Ferny revels in her poetic gifts.

Sarah and Ferny are the perfect companions in their appreciation of the beauty of their natural environment, a peaceful existence that is about to be disturbed by the local villagers’ wish to erect a ‘sacred’ bell to sound out through the stillness, a bell that Ferny equates more with the colonialist urge to assert dominion over land that is not theirs, an urge that leads to violence. Sarah and Ferny prefer to hear the noises of the night, the wind in the trees, the call of the frogmouth, indeed, the bell of the world.

Day makes reference to an Aboriginal understanding of being at one with the world, of slowness, and stillness, and appreciation of the sounds when one stops and listens, a true love of Country. It is an experience that finds another kindred soul when Sarah enters an epistolary friendship with musician John Cage, a chronicler of exotic mushrooms, and a composer of music of the ‘prepared piano’ and then of the music of silence.

The bell of the world is wondrously full of natural imagery, poetry, and meditative ideas, a book to take one’s time with, and appreciate the call to quiet thought and natural surroundings.

Themes Nature, Sounds, Music, Natural environment, Friendship.

Helen Eddy

A marriage of fortune by Anne O'Brien

cover image

The Paston family of Norwich live in difficult times. It is 1467 and the family, Margaret Mautby Paston, and her sons, Sir John and Jonty are struggling to hold on to nearby Caister Castle, a disputed inheritance from Margaret’s cousin Sir John Falstoff which cements their rather shaky position as landed gentry. Eldest daughter Margery, 20, is under pressure to marry into wealth and influence as her older brothers seem disinclined, more interested in court life, free of their mother’s marriage machinations. Margery however is more interested in the family’s bailiff, Richard Calle, ‘tall and fair, lithe and graceful' p. 9 a loyal and intelligent man she has known since childhood but a man of the merchant class without land. When it seems Margery is to be sent away to be boarded out in London to a respectable family where she might encounter a suitable husband the couple secretly make marriage vows 'per verba de praesenti' and consummate the marriage in bed. Her mother Margaret is incensed and when the couple refuse to deny their marriage Richard is dismissed and Margery turned out of the house. All this at a time in British history of instability and lawlessness as the houses of Lancaster and York battle a series of civil wars for control of the British throne. The story follows the women’s lives against this backdrop as they strive to hang on to what they have and to protect their positions and families in troubled times from the point of view of some of the main players; Margaret, her sister Elizabeth, whose Yorkist husband died on the battlefield against Lancaster (another disputed inheritance for the Pastons), Margery and Sir John’s betrothed, Mistress Anne Haute, the Queen’s cousin, a match approved by his mother but which he seems disinclined to formalise. There is a family tree at the beginning to help the reader keep abreast of the relationships and there is a family tree of the Royal Houses of Lancaster and York. Disappointingly there are no dates on either chart. The story follows these women’s lives from 1467 to 1484 through times of turbulence and change.

Lovers of women’s historical fiction will enjoy this addition to this much written about period of British history. The dialogue aims at an archaic expression and there is some reference to the clothing and fashions popular at the time. I really struggled to finish this book; at nearly 500 pages it might have been better to limit the scope either with fewer characters or a shorter timeframe. I have not read O’Brien’s previous book featuring the Pastons The Royal Game which might have made me more invested in the characters. Not quite a bodice ripper ‘my heart leapt in joy and fear beneath the confines of my gown’ p.28 but an interesting insight into the machinations of women in a male dominated society.

Themes British history, Wars of the Roses, Social standing, Family, Marriage.

Sue Speck

Jayben and the golden torch by Thomas Leeds

cover image

In a ripping fantasy tale Jayben finds himself in an alternative world, but all his memories have disappeared. A magical torch, some bizarre crystals in his hand and a compass engraved with his name are all hints at something significant. When Jayben meets the local fantasy elfin individuals in their fantasy world, unrecognisable to those of us in Earth-time and place, they are convinced that he is there to save them from the evil forces deliberately trying to block the connection between Earth and the Elf world. Many strange things are happening and there seems to be an urgent need for Jayben to rediscover some memory. Careless adults are being morphed into Null-heads, and with no cognisance of their former lives,  are becoming fantasy ‘zombies’. Jayben’s friends and the odd elf-world creatures, support him in an amazing quest. Can he discover his place in the fantasy world and save them all from evil agents by discovering his own powers and his memory before it is too late?

This has elements of the great fantasy tale – the unlikely hero, the quest, and the other-worldly magical creatures, in combination with the human dilemmas of finding one’s place in the world. Jayben (Ben) is both a ‘lost boy’ and someone wanting to find security in a strange world. The likely combination of ‘lost periods’ in his fantasy life, and the possibility of epilepsy as a cause of memory-loss are a parallel to this author’s own journey with a brain injury and epilepsy. The fantasy world Thomas Leeds has created is unique and unfamiliar, and the characters that Jayben meets and the friendships that are forged have their own intrigues. There is humour, tension, and some strange pathways through the journey to the last page, with the occasional ‘missing moments’. This is not a Harry Potter story, but it will appeal to some fantasy devotees, aged 10+, if they can cope with the occasional confusions or absences due to memory loss. I enjoyed this story, but I found that I had to read it in larger chunks in order not to lose track of the plot progress. This can certainly be recommended to readers of fantasy, and it seems that a second book involving Jayben may be coming in the future.

Themes Memories, Fantasy, Friendship, Good vs evil, Courage, Disability, Epilepsy.

Carolyn Hull

Good Neighbours by Sarah Langan

cover image

A disturbing and ruthless portrayal of the darkness of suburbia, Good Neighbours chronicles the events leading up to the fictitious 2027 Maple Street Murders. The plot is foreshadowed through the inclusion of fictitious media and scholarly reports teasing the tragedies soon to befall the characters. 

Good Neighbours is set in Maple Street, a picture-perfect slice of suburban Long Island. This illusion is shattered when, devastated by an unforgiving heatwave, suburban Queen Bee Rhea organises a neighbourhood fourth of July barbecue to lift morale. All of the families in the neighbourhood are invited, except for the Wilde family. When they decide to show up anyway, assuming that their exclusion was an accidental oversight, tensions mount. Then, the earth opens up – an enormous sinkhole emerges in the park bordering the neighbourhood crescent. 6 days later, Rhea’s daughter Shelly falls inside, frantically running with Julia Wilde towards a better future after finally unloading a dark secret. Good Neighbours follows the Orwellian, futuristic neighbourhood as poisonous accusations are thrown around, testing loyalties, and putting the Wilde family in danger, until the climactic end of the novel in which blood is finally spilled. 

Told through multiple perspectives that encourage the reader to treat the entire Maple Street neighbourhood as complicit in the tragedies that befall them, Good Neighbours is a thrilling dystopian story, exploring the notions of community, conspiracy, secrets, and betrayal. Langan asks the reader to consider whether history can ever really be truthful, and reminds us the importance of critically analysing information presented by seemingly trustful sources; fitting in the era of “fake news” and a world in which it is increasingly difficult to trust your instincts and far easier to follow the trend of those around you. 

This novel is a stunning example of the importance of literature in asking hard questions through the lens of fictional narratives, and of understanding the things that make us human. As Gertie reflects towards the end of the novel, we must never fear showing others our “mess”. That is the true meaning of togetherness. 

Recommended for students 17+ due to the distressing descriptions of death, abuse, betrayal, and violence within the novel. Also features descriptions of distressing acts of violence, including gun use, and includes brief sexual references.  

Themes Suburbia, Family, Community, Mental health, Abuse, Mystery.

Daniella Chiarolli

Indigo in the storm by Kate Gordon

cover image

Indigo in the Storm, written by acclaimed author Kate Gordon, is the companion novel to Aster’s Good, Right Things (2021 CBCA Book of the Year Winner Younger Readers) and Xavier in the Meantime (2023 CBCA Book of the Year Shortlist Younger Readers).

Indigo is angry, abandoned and withdrawn. Brought up by a disconnected, troubled and emotionally abusive mother, Indigo is left feeling worthless, fractured and alone. She was always the solitary child in the playground, the child who struggled to form friendships, the child who was seen as weird, the child who loves bugs and quietly shares her thoughts with them. When she is left by her mother, Indigo’s feelings explode, and she becomes violent and destructive. Taken in by foster mother Noni, and finding a home with Aster and her Dad, it becomes overwhelming at times for Indigo. She believes her mother may come back for her and finds it difficult to trust anyone who offers kindness and support.

Indigo’s life changes when she meets Liam, a talented graffiti artist. He has moved to Indigo’s school and makes a grand statement when he graffitied revolutionary words that resonate deep within Indigo and help her to want to do something on a grand scale and maybe then her mother might want her. Indigo and Liam are not necessarily friends, due to Indigo’s deep mistrust of forming relationships because they are easily broken, but both have an artist talent and bond over their creativity.

Indigo, Liam, Aster and Xavier become involved in a campaign to save the forest from becoming a toxic waste dump. They plan to make naturally scented soaps from sheep lanolin and will hold a stall to bring awareness to the people of the town about the potential threat to the forest. The friendships of all the children evolve and just as Indigo is learning to trust, it is unwittingly shattered. Can Indigo come back from this and finally find a sense of belonging?

Indigo in the Storm is a beautifully written and deeply moving story with ‘big’ feelings expressed and mental health issues firmly in the forefront. A wonderful read. Teacher's notes are available.

Themes Mental Health, Abandonment, Fostering, Families, Friendship, Anger, Hope, Belonging, Relationships.

Kathryn Beilby

The Spectaculars by Jodie Garnish

cover image

As a child, Harper lives a dull life in a city that doesn't celebrate creativity, so when three figures arrive at her window in a flying canoe, informing her that she is due to start her apprenticeship, Harper discovers she is a Spectacular - a magical performer, gifted special powers from the stars. Harper is thrilled to be part of the Spectaculars' travelling theatre and boarding school, until everything is plunged into great danger. With her new friends Trick and Thief, Harper sets out to save her school... But while dreams come true at the Wondria, nightmares might just be lurking in the wings...

Touted as "The Greatest Showman meets Nevermoor", this is the first in a new series for older, independent readers who can cope with a longer book with characters and events that take them beyond their immediate world. Fantasy and magic are very popular right now and I know this is one that Miss 11, who has aspirations of being a performer one day, will really enjoy.

Author Jodie Garnish introduces The Spectaculars.

Themes Fantasy.

Barbara Braxton

Prometheus High: The books of the dead by Stuart Wilson

cover image

Athena and her bunk mate, Marceline are on a mission to uncover Marceline's past - though their plans seem to be risky and teeter on getting them expelled - or killed. As if starting their new semester on a zeppelin wasn't dangerous enough, they start the term with robbing the library. Back on the ground. Nothing serious, just taking 'The Book of Creators'. A slightly contentious text. Making it back to the floating airship with seconds to spare, the pair go about attempting to uncover the secrets of the book. With the occasional help of their friend Godfrey, they learn more about the book(s), themselves and Ancient Egypt, through the course content and Professors lectures. 

The second in the Prometheus High series, The Books of the Dead is told from different perspectives, more so than the first book, which really gives a nice variety and roundness to the story. With a wide variety of characters - from fellow students to teachers, or 'creators', there are many characters to keep readers interested. Evenly paced, the novel reads quickly as it is well written. After learning a secret about Athena's bunk mate at the end of book one, Athena, and readers, are intrigued and want to learn more. Plenty of humourous questionable moral actions occur, plenty of action and adventure fill the book. A new kind of Frankenstein mixed with magic akin to the Skulduggery Pleasant series, this series may appeal to fans of these or for those interested in a quirky story. A must read for those who started the journey with the first book.

Themes Science Fiction; Fantasy; Contemporary; Adventure; Experiments; High School; Relationships; Monsters; Egypt; Mummies.

Melanie Pages

Lyle, Lyle, Crocodile: The Junior Novelization by Bernard Waber

cover image

When 12-year old Josh Primm and his family move to New York City, they are surprised to discover a crocodile living in their attic - a crocodile that is fun, playful, and can sing! Josh and Lyle become best friends but then Lyle's former owner turns up to claim him for a new musical act and despite the issues Lyle has caused with a neighbour, the Primms realise how much Lyle means to them and that they need to keep him as part of the family.

Based on the original story by Bernard Waber, this is the novelisation of the film currently so popular with young children, making it an ideal addition to any family or school collection as we encourage them to read and revisit the fun they have shared. Knowing the scenario will support those who are consolidating their skills while others may seek out the original as well as others in the series and others by the same author, expanding reading horizons beyond the screen.

The official trailer can be found here.

Themes Crocodiles, Humour.

Barbara Braxton

The heroines by Laura Shepperson

cover image

The prologue to Laura Shepperson’s version of the mythical Phaedra story sets the scene with the bard adapting his storytelling to the tastes of his audience, so the foreign princess becomes a seductress; Hippolytus, the macho son of Theseus is cheered; and the whole story is embellished to the cheers of the audience. The story is not the truth, the bard himself has no idea what the truth is, and he does not give a second thought to the hooded figures on the edge of crowd, the women, for their opinion is worthless.

At the heart of Shepperson’s story of Phaedra is a trial, the first of its kind in Athens, where the Cretan princess Phaedra accuses her step-son Hippolytus of rape. It is the word of one miserable woman against the word of the prince, in a world where women are used and abused. There is a whole chorus of women who have suffered at the hands of men. Phaedra hears their cries at night:
                It happened to me.
                And me. And me.
                Me too.
Phaedra increasingly finds the strength within herself to stand up against the mistreatment of women. But she could not find herself in a more hostile situation.

In this intriguing version of the Greek myths, Shepperson suggests that perhaps the stories of women visited by gods are the excuse that desperate women in Phaedra’s situation revert to. How can she face the return of her husband to find her pregnant to another man? So perhaps she could say she was sitting by the shore awaiting his return and was visited by the god Poseidon instead. Then her child would be half god, and must be revered.

Stories of the gods may have been invented to account for all sorts of strange events. Perhaps there is a similar explanation behind the story of her mother’s birthing of the Minotaur. Indeed, was the Minotaur even a strange beast? Phaedra knows him only as a gentle kind brother hidden away from the view of outsiders.

Stories can be twisted and turned, innocent people can find themselves reviled by the crowd, just as can occur in our present times of social media, cyberbullying and trolls. This story drawing on Greek mythology has just as much relevance today in the times of court cases and ‘me too’ protests. Shepperson’s historical fantasy novel shines a light on the world of women in ancient Greece, but can also be seen as having parallels with the situation for modern day rape victims and casualties of social media.

This is another feminist retelling of ancient stories which would definitely be a winner with readers who enjoyed Jennifer Saint’s books, Ariadne and Elektra.

Themes Greek mythology, Women, Power, Rape, Lies, Abuse, ‘Me too’.

Helen Eddy

Running with Ivan by Suzanne Leal

cover image

It's 2002 and Leo is 13. His mother has died, and his father has remarried, so Leo is not only dealing with grief but also with a new stepfamily, new home, new friends and new school. Life seems unfair and tough, and he wishes everything could go back to the way it was when his mum was still alive. 

It's 1933 and Ivan is 7. He lives in Prague with his parents and life is good. He has a big house with servants and lovely clothes and toys. But, as a Jewish family back then, it's only a matter of time before everything changes forever.

While trying to carve out some quiet space for himself, Leo finds a way to step between his own time and Ivan's. These 'visits' open his eyes to the reality of life during the leadup and outbreak of World War II, while putting his own troubles into perspective. 

Leo and Ivan form a firm friendship, each learning from and helping the other. They both love to run and running becomes not just a physical challenge and bonding experience for them, but also a way to quiet their thoughts and temporarily escape their problems. 

This is historical fiction at its very best. The timeslip formula works so well, with the storyline progressing rapidly in each timeline and keeping the reader interested and invested in the lives of both boys. The inclusion of a wise mentor in Leo's time, and a love interest in Ivan's time, are both handled with gentleness and honesty. The historical accuracy provides a real sense of dread and urgency in Ivan's timeline, while the varied relationships explored in Leo's timeline add a layer of complexity which ensure he is always seen as an equal protagonist rather than a supporting character. 

This would be an excellent choice for a class novel or book club with its many rich themes to explore.

Themes Friendship, Bereavement, Bravery, Resilience, Blended families, Holocaust, European history, World War II.

Kylie Grant

Song in the city by Daniel Bernstrom. Illus. by Jenin Mohammed

cover image

Sunday morning in the city, and Emmelene is accompanying her Grandma Jean to church where there is a choir singing and trumpets blowing and hand-clapping to hear and join in with. But Grandma Jean is getting cross because Emmelene is lagging behind because she is listening to the music of the city - the tap-tappa-tap, the yip-yippa-yip, the pitter-patter-drip and all the other sounds that her ears hear but her eyes can't see.

And in church, when Grandma Jean's music makes little impression on Emmalene , Grandma gets even crankier and just doesn't understand what Emmelene can hear - although she does try. And then Emmalene shows her...

A long time ago, I read a poem about the sounds of night falling and it made such an impression on me, that now, mosquitoes willing, one of my favourite wind-down activities is to listen to the dark creep across our bushland home. I have to admit that I'm a bit like Grandma Jean and haven't heard the music of the city so maybe I should sit in the park in town and close my eyes... Certainly, it is something we can do with our kids on a nice day - take them outside, let them lie on the grass in the sun and just listen to the music of the outdoors. And if someone falls asleep, that's fine - either they needed the rest or the activity had the desired effect of putting them in the zone for a while.

But, while this is a great book to inspire an awareness of our surroundings and be mindful in the moment, on a more practical level it is also one for exploring the concept of onomatopoeia as the sounds of the vehicles and other things that Emmelene hears are illustrated in a way that makes you see them as well as hear them. Another opportunity to explore and experience our language.

Themes Sound, Onomatopoeia.

Barbara Braxton

Unraveller by Frances Hardinge

cover image

In lyrical writing, Costa Award winning author Frances Hardinge takes us into a unique world where 'The Little Brothers', sentient spider like creatures, give people the ability to curse those they hate or who have caused them harm. Kellen is a teenager who can unravel those curses, and had helped Nettle and her brother who had been cursed into birds by their stepmother. However his ability is beginning to come apart as fabric around him unravels and he realises that he too has been cursed. When he and Nettle are approached by Gall the owner of a vicious Marsh Horse to investigate Salvation a group that is spiriting away cursers, they embark on a dangerous quest. It takes them into the mysterious Wild here terrifying creatures haunt the waters and the Moonlit Market.

Although lengthy, some 481 pages, it was easy to become totally immersed in the world that Hardinge describes in detail. She also explores layers of complexity in her themes. Are some actions bad enough to justify cursing? are the cursers evil? What happens to those whose curses are unravelled and how do they cope? What is the difference between feeling anger toward someone and hating them? Both Kellen and Nettle, in amongst their exciting adventures, must come to grips with the ways that cursing and unravelling have affected them.

With wonderful world building, unique characters, an unexpected villain and cruel creatures, Unraveller is sure to appeal to readers who enjoy complex fantasy. They may enjoy Monster Blood Tattoo trilogy by D.M. Cornish.

Themes Fantasy, Adventure, Friendship, Monsters, Curses.

Pat Pledger