Reviews

Christmas wishes by Enid Blyton

cover image

Hachette, 2020. ISBN: 9781444957198. pbk., 316pp.
After a year like no other, when things that have been taken for granted for decades have suddenly become novelties, Christmas is coming again - almost the one certainty - and people are returning to the old classic rituals and routines in a way unseen for many years. It is as though the security of the past is bringing comfort in this uncertain present and so it seems logical that we should also turn to the stories that have endured and given such joy in previous times.
If any writer of previous generations has survived that test of time it is Enid Blyton and in this collection of 30 Christmas tales taken from her series and short story collections of yesteryear, young readers will be taken back to a time when there was just the written word, the imagination and the magic. Even those who are not as old as me and who don't recall Blyton being an integral part of their reading history will revel in the sheer innocence and joy of these simple stories. From a dog who discovers the joy of Christmas to Santa Claus who gets himself out of a muddle with a little help from his friends, these stories celebrate shared times, festivities and wonder. Even if there is no opportunity to organise a full-blown Christmas Countdown, sharing just one story a day as a family or a class will bring back that sense of calm and normality in a world that seems to have gone mad.
This is a collection that holds so many memories for me that I'm passing it on to Miss 14 and Miss 9, knowing they will enjoy them regardless of their ages and that they are likely to hang on to it for that distant day of their own families. Thanks Hachette for adding to the nostalgia.
Barbara Braxton

The fifth season by Philip Salom

cover image

Transit Lounge, 2020. ISBN: 9781925760644.
(Age: Adult) Jack is a writer, and an ill man. He is intrigued by the discoveries of unidentified dead people such as the Somerton Man or the Gippsland Man, still mysteries today, and he is writing a book about them whilst sojourning at Blue Bay. There he meets Sarah, owner of the house he is staying in, a young woman obsessed with the disappearance of her sister Alice. Sarah has become a member of the Missing Persons Advocacy Network and as an artist paints large murals of the face of her sister and other missing people around the country in the hope that somebody will see them and provide a clue as to their whereabouts. The Somerton Man or the Gippsland Man must also be known and missing by somebody, surely, so their interests have some overlap and draw them together.
The story becomes complicated by the fact that the previous lodger at Sarah's house was also a writer and artist, now missing, and he has written a book about the local townspeople including Sarah, and possibly Alice, but how much is based on life or is fiction becomes very confusing. This intertwining of the known and the unknown, the real and the imagined, become threads of thoughts and ideas about life, death, art and writing. There are pages readers will want to go back over to grapple with the suggestions and possibilities.
It is a book for intellectuals, but at the same time has some really grassroot renderings of iconic Aussie conversations in the local bar, and the veggie shop, a vein of humour that lightens the tone a little.
What is the fifth season? Maybe it's another dimension, maybe it's time, maybe it's the unknown. That should give you the clue that this is not your usual mystery story. It is a challenging read, but it is full of interesting ideas, and I'm sure the book will find its readers.
Themes: Missing persons, Unidentified dead, Loss, Mortality, Obsession, Writing, Art.
Helen Eddy

The strays of Paris by Jane Smiley

cover image

Pan Macmillan, 2020. ISBN: 9781529052985.
(Age: Middle school/secondary/adult) Highly recommended. A group of animals lives on scraps and their wits around the Eiffel Tower in Paris. The horse, Paras is left in her stall after a race, and when no one comes to take her home, nudges open her gate and walks out. Following her nose she comes to a broad expanse of wonderful sweet grass, close by a very tall tower. Here, a dog called Frida befriends her, and a raven, Raoul, tags along, followed by two ducks, Syd and Nancy. The gardener chooses to ignore them, as animal issues are not his concern, people at the markets give the dog scraps and are amazed when she gives them money in return. The raven pontificates about the essence of freedom, the ducks squabble about responsibility, the rat is worried about finding a mate, and the horse just loves the fresh juicy grass and a place to roll around. They are watched by an eight year old boy, Etienne, who lives with his 97 year old blind great grandmother, and one day he takes the horse home.
A beautifully written story of friendship, the tale enfolds all readers with its humour and charm, allowing us to believe that this could really happen.
Etienne keeps the stabling of the horse in their house a secret, although several shop keepers nearby become aware that something is not quite as it should be. The baker is sure she is hallucinating to see a horse in the city streets, and gives her oats and bran, the butcher provides scraps of meat for the dog, while the greengrocer is good for carrots, apples and greens, and the gardener happy to collect the horse poo for the garden. Each separately provides for the animals as well as Etienne who shops each day for his great grandmother, but each does not think beyond themselves, only coming together after the old woman dies, to discuss what happened.
This beguiling story of love and friendship, tugs at the idea of responsibility. But all comes to a wonderful denouement, more than any reader could have hoped for, as each delicate strand is woven together to make a satisfying conclusion. The Parisian background is an absolute delight, and the characters, both human and animal whose lives we follow are astonishing in their grasp of their place in the world.
Themes: Animals, Paris, Humour, Homeless, Love, Loneliness, Freedom, Friendship.
Fran Knight

Olga by Bernhard Schlink, translated by Charlotte Collins

cover image

Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 2020. ISBN: 9781474611145.
(Age: Adult) Highly recommended. Schlink's novel begins in early 20th century Prussia, with the story of Olga, the strange girl who liked to observe; and then Herbert, the boy who tripped forward in his eagerness to go somewhere else. We read of how they are drawn to each other, the impoverished orphan and the privileged aristocrat, of how she thirsts for knowledge and he thirsts for adventure, but perhaps different forms of the same thing. Part 1 is the outline of their relationship; part 2 is Olga's later life as seamstress in the family of the young boy Ferdinand; and then part 3 is the discovery of Olga's long lost letters to her love, finally filling out the picture with all the secrets previously unknown.
Schlink grapples with questions of how could someone love a person involved in colonial African massacre, how could someone love a Nazi SS officer in charge of torture, how could it happen? Any of our preconceived stereotypes give way to the stories of real people struggling to understand and care for one another, sharing ideas and aspirations, lovers overcoming separation, and the complexities of parent relationships with child.
Olga's life is one of coming to grips with loss, lost love, lost relationships. But in the end, she determines to make her own statement, one we only discover in a surprising twist in the last pages. Schlink the master storyteller brings it all together neatly at the end, but I challenge any reader to let it rest there; I had to go back and read the story all over again and just marvel at the subtlety with which the author gradually reveals more and more of the story.
Some aspects of the book reminded me of The Dutch house by Ann Patchett (2019), a completely different story in a different setting, but what the two novels share is their portrayal of how children perpetuate the characteristics of their parents, even those aspects that most alienate them. And both novels explore themes of love, loss and obsession.
Olga is an unusually constructed novel, it gives one version of the story and then like a paintbrush over a painting, we are given another layer and then yet another. Each layer enriches our understanding. It is an intellectually rewarding novel to savour and think about long afterwards.
Themes: Love, Loss, Imperialism, Politics, Parent child relationship.
Helen Eddy

Little lion by Saroo Brierley

cover image

Illus. by Bruce Whatley. Puffin Books, 2020. ISBN: 9780143795094.
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. The incredible true story of Saroo Brierley's life is presented in this edition for younger readers, stunningly illustrated by Bruce Whatley. With 80,000 children going missing in India each year, five year old Saroo was one of many who arrived at Kolkata railway station, not knowing where he was. Falling asleep on a train the night before, he woke to find himself locked in, travelling on the train until it reached Kolkata where he was able to escape. Luckily another child took him to the police station, and from there he went to an orphanage and thence to Australia with his adoptive parents.
All the while Saroo dreamed of his home town, his mother and siblings, his house and his streets where he lived. When at university in Canberra he befriended Indian students and they encouraged him in his search using Google Maps. Over a number of years, his search continued until one night following yet another train line, he saw the water tank near his house, the bridge where he played and recognised the village where he lived.
From there he went to India to find his family, and after a small hiccup, was reunited with his mother and several of his siblings. His brother whom he loved to distraction had gone missing the same night as Saroo, an incredible double blow for his family.
Children will love reading of Saroo and his search for his family, strengthening the ties that bind us all. Brierley's tale is laudatory in its strong theme of family, as he finds that they never forgot him and welcomed his return, just as he never forgot them.
Whatley uses a range of techniques to present the story, including pastel and pencil, creating pages filled with colour, accompanied by smaller pencil illustrations underneath the text. The darker colours used to create the background of life in India, particularly when he is lost on the train, contrast with the Australian light and the colour filled pages when he finds his family. The struggle of people fitting onto the train at Kolkata station must have been overwhelming for a five year old boy from a tiny village, and this image like others n the book will create talking points for children reading of Saroo.
Subtitled, A long way home, readers will be in awe of the journeys Saroo took: locked on a train, the struggle to survive in Kolkata, living in an orphanage, the voyage to a new life in Australia, and the search for his family, followed by another journey back to India, each journey plucking at the readers' heartstrings.
Theme: India, Adoption, Homeless, Children. Loss, Village life, Google maps.
Fran Knight

Consolation by Garry Disher

cover image

Paul Hirschhausen book 3. Text Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781922330260.
(Age: Adult - Senior Secondary) Highly recommended. Disher visits the small South Australian town of Tiverton once again as Constable Paul Hirschhausen begins to investigate a series of crimes that is plaguing the region. Someone is stealing older women's underwear from their clothes lines. He has received a call about a child who might be at risk and one about a farmer who is angry about the treatment his child has received at the hands of the principal of the local school. At the same time winter is closing in and frustrations are growing.
Disher is a master at creating a setting: the dry, cold loneliness of outback of South Australia comes alive in his descriptions as Hirsch makes his routine visits to outlying farms and properties, checking that all is well with these isolated people. He knows the disparate inhabitants of the small community of Redruth, which is his patch, and the inner workings of the police in a small town and their relationship with the city police, are exposed as he traces the movements of the armed farmer and his son, so angry about everything, that they have gone on the run.
Hirsch is a likeable character who is easy to relate to. The reader can sympathise with him as he struggles to work out what to do about the young woman who appears to be stalking him, and delight in his relationship with Wendy and her daughter Katie. The wry repartee between Hirsch and many of the well-fleshed out characters in the book gives some lighter moments throughout the book.
The pace is fast and Disher juggles several sub-plots with ease drawing them all together by the conclusion of the book, giving a vivid insight into the life of a small-town police officer.
I am a fan of all of Garry Disher's books, and have really enjoyed reading about Hirsch in Consolation as well as Bitterwash Road and Peace. Fans of Jane Harper (The lost man and The dry) and Sarah Thornton's Lapse are sure to enjoy this series.
Pat Pledger

A tale of witchcraft by Chris Colfer

cover image

Hodder & Stoughton 2020. ISBN: 9781510202191.
(Age: Young Adult). Highly recommended. Brystal Evergreen and her band of magical friends are back to entertain in A tale of witchcraft, sequel to 2019's A tale of magic. The Fairy Council have defeated the evil Snow Queen and negotiated for the emancipation of women and the lawful use of magic throughout the four kingdoms. Brystal is now in charge of the magical academy founded by her mentor, Madame Weatherberry, and has welcomed magical beings from across the land to the school. However, from the novel's opening page we know that something is once again amiss. Legal tolerance of magic does not automatically equal social acceptance and the ascendance of magic users has given rise to a movement of magic-haters called the Righteous Brotherhood, who are determined to stamp out fairies and their ilk once and for all. If this isn't concerning enough, a mysterious witch with dark intentions arrives at the academy to recruit students for her rival school. Brystal knows it is only a matter of time before the mankind vs magic conflict begins again . . .
While Chris Colfer's books may be set in fantastical lands with little similarities to our own, there are always parallels to be drawn between his plots and our own society. As once marginalised and oppressed minority groups become more accepted and vocal in the community, so to do reactionary movements intent on returning things to the status quo. A tale of witchcraft is in part an allegory for our times. It is also an entertaining and fitting sequel for A tale of magic and readers will be thrilled to follow Brystal and her friends as they once again battle to save themselves, their community and all of humanity.
Themes: Magic, Magical creatures, Witches, Friendship, Cults, Adventure, Schools.
Rose Tabeni

Whitney and Britney: Chicken detectives by Lucinda Gifford

cover image

Scholastic, 2020. ISBN: 9781743836057.
Highly recommended. Whitney and Britney are back and determined to help their beloved friend Dora. The fabulous chooks are performing with Dora, having lots of fun but poor Dora is feeling glum. She is missing Gloria. The chooks are determined to help their beloved friend find Gloria and get together and hatch a plan to find her. They talk to lots of people; they even try disguises but still come up with nothing.
In the end they meet up with someone who knows what happened to her and Dora and Gloria are finally reunited. Dora is happy and they all play Jazz together.
The illustrations in this book enhance the story and help to draw the reader into the book.
I highly recommend this book. I can't wait to see what these chickens get up to next.
Karen Colliver

When this bell rings by Allison Rushby

cover image

Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760651947.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. When eleven year old Tamsin, daughter of the housekeeper, finds herself part of the investigation into the disappearance of her next door neighbour, she is at a  loss as to who to trust. Her neighbour, Edie St Clair is a well known children's novelist and is a working on the concluding chapters of her graphic novel, the last in a series of ten books called London of the Bells, so successful that journalists are camped near her front verandah, eager for an interview. Tamsin is asked inside after showing her an illustration of the min character, and once there she is drawn into the mystery, becoming part of the illustrations which cover the walls of Edie's house.
Tamsin finds herself in the world created by Edie, and here the significance of the bells of the London churches and the children's rhyme, Oranges and Lemons, takes on a sinister meaning as the ravens from the Tower of London have taken over the city, using the bells to summon the populace to do their bidding. It is a creepy world, spectacularly reflecting known aspects of London, but equally taking this knowledge and using it with an unsettling malevolence.
Cleverly entwining the story of Edie St Clair with the novel she is writing, her characters are given life as the text moves from the present to the fictional world she has created. But some of the characters seem to know why Tamsin is in their world, and even seem to understand that they are a creation of a novelist's imagination, and seem to be directing Tamsin, but she has no idea where she is going or why. Eventually Tamsin realises that they are all worried about what will happen to them when number ten is finished, and they toss her out of their world, telling her to write an ending which will please everyone, but a twist brings her much closer to their world than she expects.
Just like Tamsin, readers are mystified as to what is going on, and like her, develop a strong idea of place and time as we begin to piece the jigsaw together, enthralled at its multi layered complexity.
I loved Rushby's previous novels, The mulberry tree, The turnkey and The seven keys, and their complexity foreshadows the involving read offered in When this bell rings, a wholly engrossing and captivating story. Teacher's notes are available.
Themes: Fantasy, Graphic novel, Writing, Authors, Time travel, Characterisation.
Fran Knight

365 Real-Life Superheroes written by Valentina Camerini

cover image

Translated by Moreno Giovannoni. Piccolo Nero, 2020. ISBN: 9781760642471.
(Age: 9 - 12). Recommended. 365 Real-Life Superheroes would be a worthwhile addition to the children's section in a public library, a primary school library or classroom. This illustrated paperback is filled with short uncomplicated snapshots showcasing 365 superheroes both past and present. These include sportspeople, scientists, journalists, explorers, doctors, astronauts, musicians, artists and activists. Each person profiled has a symbol imprinted on the page to show the value or talent they have displayed. These include generosity, determination, courage, intelligence, creativity, justice and curiosity. Many of the superheroes will be unknown to both adults and students but all have contributed in some way to the betterment of the world and time they lived in or who were able to initiate change. Some of the lesser known profiles include Bill Haast who let snakes bite him and ended up donating his blood for scientific research and fifteen year old African American Claudette Colvin who refused to give up her seat on a bus for a white person and was arrested. There are more famous profiles including the band Queen who played to Soviet citizens in a time when there was animosity between the Soviet Union and the western world and Malala Yousafzai who defended everyone's right to study especially in her home country of Pakistan. Two well-known Australians profiled in the book are Lowitja O'Donoghue who was the first Aboriginal woman to study at the Royal Adelaide Hospital and Eddie Mabo who fought for the right to his land.
While this book does not contain an introduction or contents page and would benefit from both, it does have an index of those discussed. Students in the middle grades often have a fascination with the lives of people who have made changes both in recent and historical times and sharing this book with students may encourage and inspire further research. Themes: People Who Changed the World, Role Models, Non-fiction.
Kathryn Beilby

Peter and the Tree Children written by Peter Wohlleben

cover image

Illus. by Cale Atkinson. Piccolo Nero, 2020. ISBN: 9781760642518.
(Age: 5+) The author of The Hidden Life of Trees, Peter Wohlleben, has written a children's picture book, Peter and the Tree Children, which explains the connection between adult and young trees. In the story he writes about the way trees communicate between each other, how they feel and what is necessary for growth. In particular he looks at the majestic beech tree. The story begins with Piet, a little squirrel, who feels sad and alone because he does not have a family. Peter the Forester takes pity on Piet and they begin a journey through the forest. Along the way Peter shares his knowledge of trees with his focus on searching for tree children to show Piet. They find a tree-felling machine on their journey and with great sadness Peter tells Piet how the tree machine compacts the soil so young trees cannot grow. They discover a clearing where the young trees are not growing well as the soil is poor and they have no shade protection from the adult trees. Finally they find a grove of young beech saplings which have grown from beechnuts hidden by Piet last fall but which he had forgotten where he had buried them. Peter is excited by the discovery of these new tree children in the beautiful beech forest and they happily return home to the forest lodge. However Piet is still upset about not having a family and Peter offers an important solution.
The illustrations by Cale Atkinson are colourful and reflect the text well. The author provides a note for the reader in the beginning as well as facts at the end about trees and their families. Themes: Science, Nature, Environment, Trees.
Kathryn Beilby

The devil and the dark water by Stuart Turton

cover image

Raven Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781408889657.
(Age: Senior secondary/adult) Recommended. In the mid 1600s the Dutch East India Company had cornered the spice trade and were powerful, extremely rich and ruthless where trade was concerned. Turton has set his extraordinary tale aboard the Saardam sailing from Batavia to Amsterdam. Any voyage from the East Indies to Europe was dangerous, but this one had some extra dangers to contend with.
Jan Haan the Governor General of Batavia was returning home with his wife, daughter, mistress and a very valuable cargo of spices. Also on board as a prisoner is Samuel Pipps a celebrated detective on his way for trial in Amsterdam, which may lead to his execution,  and his protector Arent Hayes. Just as the company is boarding the ship a disconcerting and eerie incident takes place at the docks. A figure dressed in rags like a leper foretells disaster for the voyage before bursting into flames.
Unease among an already superstitious crew, and fear among passengers that there may be a demon among them multiplies as peculiar events take place. Strange marks appear over the ship, animals are slaughtered, the dead leper stalks the ship and a fierce storm almost sinks them.
The endpapers of this edition provides a map of the ship which shows the layout of the cabins in which many of the main characters reside. And as the book is 550 pages long, a guide is most welcome.
Stuart Turton weaves a complex mystery with its origins in the past which connects many of those on board. Greed, lust for power and revenge are the elements he uses while the Saardam itself is an oppressive force which links all the characters. There are many twists and turns in Turton's narrative which make it nigh impossible for the reader to solve the crimes committed on the ship. He creates a genuine atmosphere of fear which keeps the pages turning and the interest piqued.
Inspired by the true story of the Batavia shipwreck, one of Australia's most thrilling maritime stories, this novel is the second written by Turton, whose first novel, The seven deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle was acknowledged as Best First Novel of 2018.
Themes: Power, Dutch East India Company, Java, Batavia, Dutch East indies, Ships, Murder mystery, Historical novel.
Mark Knight

The traitor by Anh Do

cover image

Wolf Girl book 4. Allen & Unwin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760877866.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. In number four in the series, Wolf Girl, Anh Do and illustrator, Lachlan Creagh add to the adventures of Wolf Girl as she battles giant snakes and Komodo dragons.
Avoiding the forests which were full of soldiers, Gwen and Rupert struggle through the grasslands until they find a place to rest. Gwen has given Sunrise her mother's shawl to sniff and seek out the woman, but he seems disinterested. Both children are concerned that they have not found their parents, but vow to keep searching. When Sunrise disappears over night taking the shawl, Gwen is mystified. Feeling their way through dense scrub they find they are fighting an anaconda, and further on realise that they have stumbled into a derelict Reptile World. Excitement rules as they fight off the anaconda bent on eating Tiny, but escaping over the roller coaster they come across a bunch of Komoda Dragons, ready to take them all on. Eagle is able to help from the air, but the ferocity of the fight between the two children and the three dogs is intense.
A tough dystopian future is the background for this thrilling adventure series, aimed at mid to upper primary students, but also encouraging middle primary readers with the exciting and vivid illustrations, giving a darker wash to the tale.
Themes: Dystopia, Future, Adventure.
Fran Knight

Fish by Brendan Kearney

cover image

Penguin Random House, 2020. ISBN: 9780241439470.
(Ages: 4-8) As with the recent publication Mama Ocean this book addresses the significant problem of ocean pollution, however, Fish takes a much more didactic approach, explaining to the reader exactly what we can do to resolve and reverse the problem. The problem and solution is encased within the story of elderly fisherman Finn and his quest to catch a fish for dinner. We get early clues to what is coming, with rubbish floating in the water and some unhappy seals grappling with plastic bags under the water. Finn, with his dog Skip for company, is having absolutely no luck. There are no fish biting in their favourite fishing spot. 'Suddenly, Skip spotted something bobbing in the waves . . . and with a huge SPLASH he jumped in to investigate'. A double-page spread shows the reader the enormity of the situation; there is rubbish of every kind hiding just under the surface. Finn works to scoop out as much of the rubbish as he can and before long the small boat is inundated. Hungry and tired they head to shore and are met by a group of young children who offer their help. 'We're beach cleaners' the girl explained. 'We pick up litter that has been washed ashore by the tide, so that it doesn't get swept back into the sea'. What follows is the children explaining to Finn why rubbish, especially plastic, is so destructive to the ocean and what we can do on a simple level to help (recycling, repairing and reusing, avoiding single-use plastics and spreading these messages).
The book hints at the other significant ocean problem of unsustainable fishing with the juxtaposition of the huge fishing boats in the marina next to Finn's tiny wooden boat, but this is not directly addressed. It could be a conversation starter though. There is a nice message here for children about their ability to influence attitudes and make a difference in the world. It also reflects the current climate where young people are taking a stand for the environment, educating older people and becoming harbingers of change. Unfortunately, the didactic portion of the book feels a little tacked on to the actual story and the seemingly instant revival of the ocean a little too optimistic. Themes: Ocean pollution, Rubbish and recycling.
Nicole Nelson

Aster's good, right things by Kate Gordon

cover image

Riveted Press, 2020. 189pp. ISBN: 9780648492573.
(Ages 11+) Highly recommended. Aster is an 11-year-old girl who attends an alternative style school in Tasmania. We soon learn, through her first-person journal, that she is troubled and on the outer and more importantly we know what she is thinking in contrast to how she is acting. She also has an interest and passion for flowers and their symbolism. Aster is convinced that the only way she can survive is by doing good, right things for others but she rarely feels accomplishment or joy for herself.
She volunteers most of her school breaks in the library but one day she finds refuge in the school yard and meets Xavier and his rabbit Hollyhock. Their friendship grows through their openness about their mental health and Xavier's quirky dress and behaviour. Another important character at the school is Indigo who thwarts her need of love and rescuing behind aggressive behaviour. On the home front Aster's mother has left her and Aster's loving father. This has a huge impact on them both and Aster blames herself. Fortunately, her Aunt Noni supports them and then Indigo as well. Gradually Aster develops a group of like-minded friends around her and we have hope for their futures. Ultimately intelligent communication and love heals all their lives.
There are certainly other stories with characters experiencing anxiety and depression, family breakup and friendship issues. However, this story is deeply perceptive and true. It is right to acknowledge that all mothers don't love their children and that adults can be selfish and unwise. Kate Gordon captures the physicality of anxiety and the need to hide away. Gordon really gets into the mind of an 11-year-old and short unflowery sentences convey Aster's astute thoughts well. Sometimes these strings of thoughts are quite poetic.
Stories like these are so important for developing empathy for others. It suits a middle years audience well because it is not too graphic and shocking. Although it is a serious book it does have a whimsical quality which matches Aster's personality.
Teacher's notes are available.
Jo Marshall