Reviews

There's something weird about Lena by Sigi Cohen

cover image

Illus. by James Foley. Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760651503.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. With intricate digital illustrations to pour over, kids will laugh uproariously as the story unfolds, leading the audience to think about what Lena actually is. Her strange behaviour, playing pranks on other kids at school, ranges from the innocuous putting gum on someones' hair to scaring someone half to death, putting worms down someone's back to letting loose a bag of snakes in the classroom. Each prank causes distress to those against whom it is perpetrated, and they decide it is high time they did something about Lena. Several of her classmates dress in spooky costume and go to Lena's house, but their moans and wails attract the attention of a giant hyena from inside the house. It chases them to a convenience store where they attempt to hide and are surprised when Lena suddenly appears. By now readers will have made a link between the rhyming words Lena and hyena and laugh out loud as the story comes to a conclusion.
Told in rhyming stanzas, kids will get a second layer of fun in predicting the rhyming word in each couplet, while the illustrations aptly support the fun of the tale, and evoke another level of interest and involvement. Kids will watch out for hints of Halloween, and love the endpapers with their differing views of Lena changing from a young girl in the first instance to a hyena in a girl's dress at the end. I love the scattering of bones, the headstones, the recognisable school rooms and excursions and the use of shadows to create feelings of unease.
I loved the array of plants in the school grounds, the posters on the classroom walls, the looks on the kids' faces. The detail is engrossing and adds to the fun of reading this enticing book.
A fitting second book from the Perth based team which created My dead bunny (2015). A book trailer is available.
Themes: Halloween, Horror, School, Pranks.
Fran Knight

The Windsor diaries 1940-45 by Alathea Fitzalan Howard

cover image

Hodder & Stoughton, 2020. ISBN: 9781529328097.
The author of the diaries (edited by her niece-in-law Isabella Naylor-Leyland to whom they were bequeathed) was born in 1923 to an aristocratic Catholic British family. She would have been the next Duke of Norfolk had she been a male.
Alathea recorded her life in diary entries from January 1939 until she died in January 2001, but only the 1940 to 1945 war years when she lived with her grandfather in a grand house near the Princesses Elizabeth and Margaret at Windsor are covered in the book.
Given her social status, mention of famous people of the time are frequent. What stood out to me was Alathea's obsession with becoming and remaining part of the 'royal circle' to the extent of acting and dressing younger than her years to be closer in age to the princesses.
As appropriate to her age at the time, the entries are often of a shallow nature - what she and others wore and ate, visited, liked/hated, marriage, etc. Some entries indicated a very troubled (self harming) teenager, with an ambivalent relationship to her parents.
The war and its effects are only incidentally touched upon. The references to food, clothes, parties, etc are not indicative of great war time hardships. Having to undertake mandatory war work appears to be resented as an intrusion on Alathea's social life.
The diary entries reflect the class distinctions and prejudices of the time and Alathea's main preoccupation besides continuing the friendship of the royals is love and marriage to a suitable aristocratic man (but not a 'second son'). She does appear to have insight that the aristocratic way of life with servants, leisure, etc is a thing of the past - which she greatly regrets.
Not a gripping book, but useful as an insight into the effect of WWII on a small segment of upper class British people. The diaries could be used as a primary source by History students to compare WWII experiences of upper and other class teenagers. For those interested in the British royal family, there are some insights into the daily life of the royal family during the time spent at Windsor during WWII.
Ann Griffin

Norton and the Bear by Gabriel Evans

cover image

Berbay Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9780648785132.
(Ages: 3-8) Highly recommended. Intricate, delicate illustrations accompany this story about individualist Norton (a poodle living in what has the feel of a French village). He finds a jumper that is very different to what everyone else is wearing and he is really happy about his uniqueness. That is until a bear sees him and decides he needs one too! He adds a scarf to his outfit but soon enough he runs into the bear again. 'That scarf is the perfect accessory for this jumper. I must get one'. And he does. The bear is ecstatic that they are so similar, but Norton is appalled. He runs and hides and tries again and again to feel unique, with a hat and then socks and then a flower in his hat. But no matter what he does the bear is there and is copying him. Finally he cracks; 'Stop copying me!', he shouts. When the roles are reversed and Norton sees the bear sporting a new addition to his outfit Norton realises that wearing the same clothes doesn't really matter as he and Bear are both very different anyway and perhaps the bear just wants to be his friend?
All primary-aged children, most of whom love to copy others but despise being copied themselves, will identify with this story. The humour will grab children as they will see their own overreactions within Norton's despair at Bear and his copying. This is a simple, meaningful and visually stunning book that reminds us all that what we look like on the outside doesn't matter nearly so much as what we are like on the inside. It also provides a fun way to talk about why imitation is so annoying and why people copy others (for children it is generally because they want to be friends or want to be more socially accepted). It's a useful reminder to be more tolerant of others and to let go of the small things that bother us and be more empathetic. Themes: Individuality, Belonging.
Nicole Nelson

Catvinkle and the missing tulips by Elliot Perlman

cover image

Ill. by Laura Stitzel. Puffin Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760894382.
(Age: 9-11) Recommended. This is the second book in the Catvinkle series, following The adventures of Catvinkle published in 2018 as Elliot Perlman's first children's novel. Although the characters are mostly the same, and there is some reference to what has happened previously, there is no need to have read the first book as this story can stand alone.
Catvinkle is a fluffy white cat who lives with her dalmatian friend Ula and their human. In this book they are called on to help two sheep accused of nibbling on Amsterdam's famous tulips.
The story is quite complex and involves assistance from a curious range of animals as well as travel to another country. The central question of what happened to the tulips keeps the reader guessing till the very end.
Throughout the story there are explicit lessons about empathy, fairness, inclusion, looking after the environment, telling the truth and doing whatever you can to stand up and speak up for others who are less fortunate.
There is a timely reminder, too, about stopping to think whether information can be trusted, especially if you hear something bad about someone. It covers the questions you should ask yourself to verify information and one of the animals clarifies "So just because someone says or even tweets something, doesn't mean it's true?" This is an excellent message for students to absorb before they reach the age where they really start engaging with social media.
Students who enjoy books with morals or messages will love this one.
The black and white illustrations by Melburnian Laura Stitzel are very sweet and do a great job of adding to this story.
Themes: Animals, Friendship, Fairness, Empathy, Environment.
Kylie Gran

Colin Cockroach goes to Caloundra by Chris McKimmie

cover image

Ford St Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781925804553. (Age: 4+) Highly recommended. When Colin decides to follow the smell coming from upstairs, he embarks on a wonderful holiday north of Brisbane, unwittingly hitching a ride with the family which has left because of the cockroach infestation. They leave a cockroach bomb in the house to rid it of the pests and take a holiday while the fumigant does its job. But Colin is in one of their paper bags along with an assortment of necessaries for a holiday: suncream, chocolate, paper towels and chips.
He goes north past the Glasshouse Mountains and the big pineapple. He spies a koala and a budgie and when he gets to Caloundra he dons his flippers and snorkel to wander along the beach. Then he rides a wave or two before being spotted, and everyone runs away, even the shark. That evening sees him at the disco where he dances the night away with Kylie the crab. All the facets of a good holiday: sun, surf, things to see, good food and a romantic interlude!
When the time comes for him to return to his family, he finds they are not where he left them and he fears the roach bomb has done its work, but rest easily, there is a happy ending.
McKimmie's way of seeing the humble cockroach is most endearing; through his eyes we see an insect like those we spy on the kitchen floor, but readers will now take a second look as they trip across to the toilet late at night. Not only does McKimmie impel a second look at this insect, but he also showcases a tourist's view of Queensland from Brisbane to Caloundra, inviting readers to have a look for themselves.
His entertaining illustrations reflect a sophisticated naivety, using a seemingly childlike technique which invites readers to look more closely at how they are produced. They will see a range of skills using collage, gouache, pencils and watercolour amongst the many forms of illustration used to produce the spindly Colin and the plethora of detail on each page.
Witty, laugh out loud, ingenious, Colin Cockroach goes to Caloundra is a story begging to be read over and over again, poring over the intricate drawings, children making an effort to replicate what they see.
And I am sure they will want to read more of the adventures of Colin Cockroach.
Themes: Cockroaches, Insects, Adventure, Queensland.
Fran Knight

Show me the money by Sue Lawson and Karen Tayleur

cover image

Wild Dog, 2020. ISBN: 9781742035895.
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Show me the money is a contemporary non-fiction publication which gives the reader a detailed look at Australia's money. The Contents page clearly sets out the topics for an easy search for the required information. The book begins with the history of money in Australia and then moves onto our coins, and banknotes. Each note is clearly explained with a large coloured image and information links to all the different details. The key figures on each note are explained with a timeline of important dates and an interesting biography. There are fast facts at the end, a conclusion and a comprehensive timeline showing Before Colonisation to 2020 Next generation of notes. The book also contains a glossary, an index and a list of pictures and images used throughout the book.
This informative book would be a valuable resource in any school and public library. Teacher's notes are available. Themes: Australian money, Banknotes, Coins, History.
Kathryn Beilby

A clock of stars: The shadow moth by Francesca Gibbons

cover image

Illus.by Chris Riddell. HarperCollins, 2020. ISBN: 9780008355036.
(Young Adult / Children). Highly recommended. A brilliant new fantasy author has been found in Francesca Gibbons. Her debut novel A clock of stars: The shadow moth, aimed at older children and younger teens, is a fun and easy read. The story centres on sisters Imogen and Marie who follow a moth through a hidden doorway in a tree and end up in another world. Like Alice and her rabbit, Imogen and Marie find fun, adventure and peril in this alternate universe. In this world ruled by an evil king where conflict bubbles beneath the surface, the sisters meet lonely Prince Milo who agrees to help them find their way home if they will be his friends and help him restore peace to the realm.
What a coup for Gibbons to have secured Chris Riddell as her illustrator. A prolific and well-loved children's illustrator and author himself, Riddell's work has appeared in many books, including those by Neil Gaiman and J.K. Rowling. His signature style is apparent upon opening the book, immediately drawing the reader into Gibbons' fantasy world.
Although pitched at a juvenile audience, adults and older teens will also find themselves enthralled by the world-building, magic and wonderful illustrations. A little bit Alice in Wonderland, a little bit Narnia and very much its own, A clock of stars is highly recommended. Themes: Magic, Magical creatures, Royalty, Sisters, Family, Friendship, Animals.
Rose Tabeni

Aussie Kids: Meet Matilda at the festival by Jacqueline de Rose-Ahern

cover image

Illus. by Tania McCartney. Puffin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760894511.
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Eight stories in the Aussie Kids series, each set in one of the states and territories of Australia, will appeal to those who have just achieved competency at reading chapter books. Each of these books is short, with brief chapters, well set out for early readers, highly illustrated and published in a clear well spaced font. The stories are evocative of life in each of the settings, and this one, set in Canberra, conjures up the lifestyle with its embassies and variety of people from around the world.
Matilda's father works for the government and so she has access to people from the embassies. Her close friend is Hansuke from the Japanese Embassy and she knows his house with its screens and quiet gardens as well as he knows hers, with its kangaroos in the park nearby.
A festival to celebrate the Emperor's birthday is held at the embassy and Matilda and her family join in each year. Mum and Matilda wear their kimonos and Matilda has a special goodbye present for Hansuke, as his family moves back home, a scrapbook of all their adventures in Canberra.
As they turn the pages of the scrapbook, Matilda finds it hard to keep back her tears, but Hansuke has a surprise for her when a new ambassador from Ireland comes with a daughter her age. She knows Hansuke well and has heard about Matilda, so they are instant friends.
The clear easy to read text gives the reader a feeling for life in Canberra, and Japanese words appear in the text, giving an authenticity to the story. I can imagine classes wanting to try out origami or the Japanese food mentioned in passing, and certainly the story gives them a tourist's view of what there is to see in the nation's capital.
Themes: Japan, Canberra, Friendship, Festivals, Aussie Kids (series).
Fran Knight

Combat Wombat to the rescue by Gina Newton

cover image

Illus. by Tiffanee Daley. Ford Street Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781925804577.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Combat Wombat to the rescue is a beautifully illustrated picture book about Australian animals trapped in a bushfire. They are led to safety by Combat Wombat Wildlife Warrior who has discovered he has a super-sensitive nose, ears and paws. Along their journey to safety they overcome obstacles including outwitting sneaky Dingo Bingo, to finally arrive on Billabong Island where they can relax and play.
This is a perfect read aloud for younger students and has all the elements children love - danger, excitement and a hero to save the day! However the story could also be used as a lead-in to a unit of work on Bushfires for all primary aged students. Ford Street Publishing has developed a comprehensive Teacher resources pack to supplement the book. The topics covered include:
1. Habitat is home
2. Fire in the bush
3. Aboriginal peoples and fire
4. To the rescue!
As well as curriculum links to HASS, English and Science for Foundation to Year 3, the resources also look at sustainability and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Histories and Cultures. There are printable worksheets at the end of the pack.
The stunning illustrations by Tiffanee Daley perfectly complement the simple text. She has created a series of behind the scenes videos showing how she completes her drawings from the storyboard concept, found on her YouTube channel.
Themes: Wombats, Bushfires, Australian bush, Australian animals.
Kathryn Beilby

The secret garden: the story of the movie by Frances Hodgson Burnett and Linda Chapman

cover image

HarperCollins, 2020. ISBN: 9780008340070. 224pp., pbk.
First published in 1911, The secret garden is the story of Mary, a sickly, neglected, unloved and unwanted 10-year-old girl whose care has been mostly left to the servants who care for her English family in colonial India. After her parents die in a cholera epidemic, she is sent back to England into the care of her unknown uncle Archibald Craven at his isolated mansion Misselthwaite Manor on the Yorkshire Moors. At first, Mary is rude and obnoxious, disliking everything about her new circumstances but eventually she warms to Martha Sowerby who tells her about her aunt, the late Lilias Craven and how she would spend hours in a private walled garden growing roses. After his wife died in an accident in the garden, Mr Craven locked the garden and buried the key. Mary becomes interested in finding the secret garden herself and once she discovers the key, her life begins to change.
This version is based on the screenplay of the 2020 movie which has finally been released and which many students will have seen. Telling the core of the original story it evokes a magical world that encourages self-discovery and change and perhaps an interest in reading the original. A stunning way to introduce a new generation to a classic. Watch the official trailer on YouTube.
Barbara Braxton

Harrow Lake by Kat Ellis

cover image

Penguin, 2020. ISBN: 9780241397046.
(Age: 15+) Recommended. Ideal for Halloween, this thriller/horror story is one that will keep readers glued to the page as they follow the trials of Lola Nox, the daughter of a horror filmmaker. With her father is founded with multiple stab wounds, she is sent off to stay with the grandmother that she has never met. The rural town of Harrow Lake was the setting for Nolan Nox's most famous horror film and the place where her mother was brought up. The town has used this setting as a tourist attraction and each year there are unexplained disappearances which are never solved. Some bizarre occurrences, a strange puppet like creature called Mister Jitters, legends about cannibalism and weird tapping noises set the scene for some very scary moments as Lola tries to find out what happened to her mother Lorelei who abandoned her as a young child.
The pace is fast, and the book is hard to put down, indeed it is one that many readers will want to finish in one or two sittings, holding their breathes as they read. There are some truly memorable scenes like a dead tree that has hundreds of teeth hanging from it, and a frightening group of caves, housing a derelict church.
Lola is not a person who the reader will readily identify with in the beginning but as the story unfolds, the reader will get to know what her life has been like with a totally controlling father and will begin to sympathise with her. It is hard to tell the truth from what could be her wild imaginination. Is her friend Mary Ann really appearing to her? What is the meaning of the secrets that are written on bits of paper and hidden and why did Lorelei collect strange bug like creatures? Is someone stalking her? Can she trust Carter the young man who has befriended her? What is her grandmother hiding and where has Lorelei disappeared to?
Fans of thrillers and horror stories will find Harrow Lake difficult to put down and will have fun working out the truth in Lola's unreliable narrative and enjoy the horror tropes of a scary town with strange people, stalkers, dark woods and horrifying puppets.
Pat Pledger

Piper picks the perfect pet by Caroline Tuohey

cover image

Illus. by Nicole Johnston. Ford St Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781925804591.
(Ages: 3+) Highly recommended. Starting the book with the lines,
My Dad says I can chose a pet
But I'm not sure what pet to get
will fire the imaginations of all readers as they choose a pet along with the narrator.
And with every good verse story, the lines entice readers to predict the rhyming word as the pages are turned.
The choices are numerous, from a bouncy dog or a flouncy dog, a puddly dog or a jumpy dog, a perhaps a tabbly or Persian cat, a donkey, an axolotl, a horse or ferret. Every different sort of pet is illustrated and questioned over its suitability, until finally at a pet show at school, the narrator's choice is revealed.
A fun read, supported by delightfully comic illustrations, the verse tale will entreat and captivate readers, many of whom will have had the same dilemma, what pet to chose, and those that have not had to make this choice will be equally charmed, thinking about possibilities to come.
Johnston's pencil and watercolour illustrations reveal a playful family life, fill of animals and a supportive school which has a pet show to encourage and involve students. The antics of each of the animals portrayed reveals a subtle humour as they are shown in various guises. A poodle taking its place along the chaise lounge, a large dog taking up the whole chair, a Manx cat playing with the mouse, a donkey refusing to budge, while a goat takes its master up the hill. Children will laugh out loud at the antics of each animal as the pages are turned, wondering which one to choose for themselves and for the narrator. And there is a prize for every pet. Teacher's notes are available.
Themes: Animals, Pets, Humour, Choices, Alliteration.
Fran Knight

Chickensaurus by James Foley

cover image

S.Tinker Inc. series. Fremantle Press, 2020. ISBN: 9781925815788.
(Age: Primary) Recommended. Chickensaurus is the fourth book in the S.Tinker Inc. series that follows the tales of Sally Tinker and her gang as they invent a plethora of wondrous things (including robots, giant dung beetles and tiny submarines to investigate her brothers insides!) with this story surrounding her arch enemy turning chickens into monstrous dinosaurs.
Sally and her crew are forced to flee into the maze to try and escape the crazy trifeathertops and the pteroducktyl, however they eventually end up in the basement where all sorts of unexpected things happen . . .
This graphic novel was written with middle primary aged children in mind, and was perfect for my year 4, 10 year old. He thought it was a great book, and especially loved the illustrations and the idea of morphing a chicken and a dinosaur. He felt that lots of kids he went to school with would like the book, and wanted to tell the school librarian to look into this title and the other three in the series.
I also thought it was a good, easy enough read that would suit the middle primary bracket, but I think it would be most beneficial to readers who may struggle with short novels, or younger students who want a challenge. I enjoyed the flow of the stories conversation and found myself easily giving characters accents and voices. I think that James Foley has done a really good job in drawing in a wide variety of readers at different engagement and skill levels. The illustrations really help the story too, with the characters showing emotions and the Chickensaurus being quite amusing.
After finishing the book I wanted to check out the other 3 in the series as I enjoyed the characters, story and the illustrations so much!
Overall I think James Foley is a very good writer, and one that deserves to be on my children's book shelf. He has written a number of other books, plus some short stories which we will definitely be looking into. 4 out of 5 for Chickensaurus. Teacher's notes are available.
Lauren Fountain

What Zola did on Wednesday by Melina Marchetta

cover image

Illus. by Deb Hudson. Puffin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760895174.
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. What Zola did on Wednesday is the third story in the humorous and entertaining Zola series. Zola lives with her Mum and Nonna Rosa and is very busy with the garden project after school on Monday and playing with her neighbours and Nonna's knitting grandmothers on Tuesday. In this new story Zola hears something going on in Leo's yard and climbs a tree to investigate. Leo's mother Justine is a police officer and has brought home Vesper the police dog for a visit. Justine tells Zola all about the work a police dog does and when Sophia's turtle goes missing Zola comes up with an idea. The idea does not quite go as expected and the neighbours all support Zola and her friends and keep them safe. Justine talks to the children about being careful and visits Zola's school for her news talk. Justine also organises dog training on Wednesdays after school and Zola and her friends are kept busy.
The multi-cultural community aspect of this series shows the diversity of the Australian culture and how we can all interact positively with others in our daily lives. At the end of the story the author shares tips for training your pet dog to sit. This book would be a lovely read-aloud for a classroom teacher or parent and an excellent read for a young child moving onto independent reading. Themes: Friends, Neighbours, Diversity, School, Dogs, Safety.
Kathryn Beilby

Watch over me by Nina LaCour

cover image

Text Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781922330604.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. After being in the foster system since her mother abandoned her, 18-year-old Mila is looking forward to her job, teaching a young, home-schooled child on a farm. She is desperate for a home, a place where she can belong and hopes to find it with Terry and Julia, who own the farm and with the other people there, particularly Billy and Liz and her small charge, Lee. What she does not know when she accepts the job is that something strange is going on there and that it will bring back all the bad memories of her past.
An eerie combination of ghosts and ordinary life on a farm, LaCour manages to keep the suspense alive as Mila's story gradually unfolds. What are the ghostly figures that danced at night and why did everyone except for Lee and her wear gold bracelets and pendants? And what happened to the girl who used to teach Lee? Where has she gone? The story has a gothic feel and I almost felt that I was reading a novel set in the 1800's, until there would be a reference to driving to a market with flowers or using a phone.
In lyrical prose the author describes bit by bit the memories of the trauma that Mila had undergone when young, and the struggle that she is having with them resurfacing. Lee has also suffered trauma and Mila tries her best to help him, even as he sees ghosts too.
This is a disturbing read, with undertones of domestic violence, abandonment, guilt and grief, all part of Mila's struggle to accept her past and find a new home. Add a mix of ghosts, fear and mystery, and Watch over me will grip the reader until its powerful conclusion. Teacher's notes are available from the publisher.
Pat Pledger