Reviews

The Little Engine that could by Watty Piper

cover image

Illus. by Dan Santat. Penguin Random House, 2020. ISBN: 9780593094396.
(Ages: 3-7) A classic children's tale first published in 1930, The Little Engine that could shows the power of kindness and determination. This 90th anniversary edition has a heartfelt introduction by Dolly Parton and vibrant illustrations by Dan Santat, complete with wide open spaces, sunlit fields and blue skies. The text is completely unchanged from the original so is a little outdated (the train is still carrying jackknives and glass bottles of creamy milk for the boys and girls) but this simply adds to the magic and timelessness of the story as a whole.
For those unfamiliar with the story, a happy little train is taking toys and good things to eat to the little boys and girls on the other side of the mountain. So when the red engine breaks down suddenly, the toys and dolls attempt to get passing engines to help them across the mountain. The shiny new passenger engine thinks itself far too superior to pull the likes of the little train, the strong freight engine thinks itself far too important and the dingy, rusty old engine is simply too tired to even try. 'I can not. I can not. I can not' he chugs as he rumbles off. But the little blue engine who comes by thinks of the desperate toys and dolls who need her help and of the good little boys and girls waiting for their toys and good food. 'I think. I can. I think I can. I think I can', she says as she tugs and pulls the train over the mountain. The toys are ecstatic and the little blue engine is proud of herself and her self-belief.
There is a reason this is a classic and it stands up amazingly to the test of time. Its simple message is still as relevant as it was 90 years ago: the world needs us to do our very best and being kind and understanding is just as important as ever. The story shows that the act of one humble being can have great effect on many, a message that we want to convey to all our young people who have the potential to change the world for the better. Themes: Trains, Determination, Self-belief.
Nicole Nelson

The New Baby's Bunny by Philippa Brown

cover image

Illus. by Krista Brennan. Little Steps Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781925839029.
(Ages: 3-7) There is a new baby on the way and Nanna is knitting a special bunny for its arrival. Told through one of the three older siblings, the story tells about the bunnies Nanna knitted for each of the older children when they were born and how loved they still are. 'My big brother's bunny is brown with black eyes. When my big brother goes to school, his bunny watches over his room'. The bunny for the new baby is all finished but Nanna is having trouble finding the right buttons for the eyes. Can the children help? Off to the haberdashery go the family, each choosing what they think could be the perfect button eyes. Dad's buttons are a bit big, Mum's are too dark and the buttons chosen by the two brothers are very interesting but not quite right. It is the green buttons chosen by our narrator that are perfect.
It is great to see a diverse family representation in an Australian picture book and a larger family, not often seen in picture books. The soccer ball and train buttons chosen by the brothers will probably elicit a giggle or a smile. This is a pleasing depiction of a family respectfully and jointly preparing for the arrival of a new baby and the illustrations are full of love, calm and thoughtfulness. An ordinary family and a simple gesture of love. Themes: New baby, Comfort toys.
Nicole Nelson

Mabel and the mountain by Kim Hillyard

cover image

Ladybird, 2020. ISBN: 9780241407929.
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Subtitled, A story about believing in yourself, the wide eyed creature in a smart knitted hat invites the reader to look further inside, if only to know what this creature is. We find out soon enough as her route is tracked over the intervening pages before the story starts, further intriguing the reader. Mabel is a fly, and Mabel has some very big plans. Her list of things to do fills a page: climb a mountain, host a dinner party and make friends with a shark. Readers' imaginations will soar with Mabel, wondering how a little fly can achieve such momentous things. When she announces her plans to her friends, they all say lots of negative things: no, stay at home, flies do not climb, ridiculous and it can't be done. These derisive comments do not deter Mabel. She finds a mountain to climb and climbs, passing other climbers with all the right gear, seeing animals that threaten, wondering if she has the courage to go on. But a voice tells her to keep going and she does, arriving at the top of the mountain, thrilled at what she sees. Returning she finds things have changed: her friends are no longer derisive, but making plans of their own, asking her what her next plan is.
And children reading this lovely positive picture book will do just that: dream about their own big plans and, like Mabel, start straight away. Like me, readers will look closely at the detail on each page: the funny fly faces, the things they are dressed in and what they are holding, the way each fly is made different with what seems like a few strokes of the pen. A wonderfully positive read, sure to encourage readers to believe in themselves. Themes: Mountains, Self awareness, Challenges, Adventure.
Fran Knight

The switch by Beth O'Leary

cover image

Quercus 2020. ISBN: 9781787475007.
(Age: Adult) Leena has a job she loves, lives in a trendy flat in Shoreditch, London, which she shares with flatmates Martha, Yaz and Fitz. But since the death from cancer of her sister, Carla, she has been having panic attacks and making mistakes at work. She feels horror and shame when her boss insists she take two months leave. Leena is close to her 79 year old grandmother Eileen who lives in Hamleigh-in-Harkdale. When Leena visits her she finds a list of unattached men in the small village; Eileen is looking for a new relationship since husband Wade left her. Leena suggests an online dating service but there are not many local entries for the older age group. London offers many more and from this is born the idea of swapping places while Leena is on leave. Eileen agrees, partly for a bit of fun but also to break down the barriers between Leena and her mum Marian, who lives nearby. She has also been struggling to cope since Carla's death and mother and daughter have barely spoken. So as Eileen embraces London life Leena sets out to fill her place in everything from Neighbourhood Watch meetings, dog walking, visiting Marian and organising the local May festival.
As we follow the narrative, alternating between the point of view of overachiever Leena and pragmatic Eileen the value of a change of perspective becomes apparent. The characters are funny and engaging and the comedy lightens the messages about caring for one another, the importance of family, acknowledging grief and of course finding love. A light read for women.
Sue Speck

Where's Spot? by Eric Hill

cover image

Spot the Dog. Puffin, 2020. ISBN: 9780241446850. Board book.
(Age: 0+) Highly recommended. With a gorgeous ruby cover to celebrate 40 years since the publication of this classic picture book, young and old alike will delight in the simple story of Sally trying to find Spot the little puppy. She looks in all sorts of places, under the stairs, in a box, under the rug, but Spot is not there. Instead she finds an array of smiling creatures, a crocodile, a snake, a bear, and a hippopotamus until she finally finds him and gives him his dinner.
The gentle refrain of "Is he in the . . . "; "Is he under the . . . " will be one that children can repeat along with the reader and then shout out a resounding "No." There will be opportunities for children to play hide and seek themselves and peek-a-boo after reading the story. The simple repetition and large print will also help emerging readers as they repeat familiar pages.
The pages are sturdy and the lift-the-flaps are big enough for little fingers to handle. What makes it so special are the big images of Sally the dog, outlined in black and the vivid colours that children are sure to enjoy.
This is a lovely book that will bring back memories to the generations who have read it aloud to children. Now their children have the opportunity to read it to their children as a board book and grandparents will be overjoyed to bring back memories with this gift to their young grandchildren as well.
Pat Pledger

Deep water by Sarah Epstein

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760877286.
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Chloe misses her friend Henry and is determined to solve the mystery of his disappearance. Following a violent storm one night, the only clue to Henry's whereabouts is his mountain bike leaning against the train station wall. Did he just leave, as he once hinted he might do, or did something terrible happen to him?
Epstein's novel switches between Chloe narrating in the present, and past snippets of Henry's online messages with a mysterious friend, and chapters about Henry's brother Mason in the lead-up to the eventful night. Both Henry and Mason suffer from abuse by their alcoholic mother Ivy. The early scenes depicting their home life are so ugly, with no insight into any redeeming characteristics for their mother, that some readers may find it hard to engage with the narrative, but once past those pages, the mystery about Henry's disappearance, and the clues that Chloe unearths, leads the reader on a twisting path of suspicion and conjecture that holds our attention until the last pages.
Chloe's detective work points to Mason; and we know that Mason himself is afraid of his own anger. Is he a product of his parents - son of an abusive mother and a criminal father: is he bad, empty, worthless? Is he set on a path that he cannot change?
Chloe and her circle of friends gradually uncover the events of the night of the big storm, there are many misleading clues and red herrings that Chloe determinedly investigates one after another. No adult seems willing to help. Suspicions turn from one person to another, but most suspicious of all is Mason, the boy within their friendship group. Chloe does not give up, until suddenly she finds herself confronting a danger she had not predicted.
This is an engaging mystery thriller that readers of this genre will thoroughly enjoy. Teacher's notes are available. Themes: Murder, Mystery, Child abuse, Anger management.
Helen Eddy

Weirdo 14: Vote Weirdo! by Anh Do

cover image

Illus. by Jules Faber. Scholastic, 2020. ISBN: 9781743836668.
(Age: 7-9) Weirdo 14: Vote Weirdo! is the latest entertaining story in the Anh Do series and begins with Weir Do and his classmates choosing students to run for Class Captain. Weir Do, Bella Allen and Hans Some are nominated for a number of different reasons. Weir Do rushes home to tell his family but discovers his father has bought hair clippers. His father is a serial collector of junk and this time the consequences for Weir are highly embarrassing especially as he is about to begin his campaign for Class Captain. Fortunately Henry and his father are able to help Weir Do cover up the slightly awkward problem. The campaign involves creating posters, presenting three ways to improve the school and giving a speech to the class. Bella and Weir Do complete this admirably but Hans Some with his sky writing campaign, egocentric ways to improve the school for himself and parent written speech misses the mark. An unfortunate event with a gust of wind ends Weir Do's chances of winning but in the end everyone is satisfied.
The illustrations by Jules Faber create added interest in the story and the bright blue theme begins with the cover and continues throughout the book. This fourteenth book in the series is perfect for those younger students discovering chapter books, reluctant readers or just for those children who can relate to a light, humorous and quick read. Themes: Humour, Friends, School, Family, Recycling, Voting.
Kathryn Beilby

Eloise and the bucket of stars by Janeen Brian

cover image

Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760651879.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Eloise Pail lives in a soulless place, the Children of Paradise Orphanage, rivalling Jane Eyre's Lowood Institution for cruelty and privation.
Nearly thirteen she is burdened with many of the tasks to keep the place running by the vindictive head nun, Sister Hortense. A nastier protagonist is hard to find, and readers will squirm seeing the ways Sister Hortense makes Eloise's life miserable. Eloise longs for a family, but knows nothing of her background. Her name has been given her by the institution, her surname Pail from the bucket in which she arrived at the orphanage as a baby in 1807.
She goes to the village each day to fetch water and always stops to talk to the blacksmith's horse. She dreams of what a family might be like while talking to the stars at night, her only friends. But Hortense seems to have a second sense about Eloise's veering from her duties and is quick to punish.
One day in the village Mr Jackson, the smithy gives her a piece of paper to decipher with a drawing of a unicorn on it. Already punished by Sister Hortense for telling the younger orphans a story about unicorns, Eloise keeps the stories to herself, writing them on a scroll she keeps on her person.
When a new girl, Janie Pritchard arrives at the orphanage Eloise takes a long time to trust her. She watches Eloise, asking questions, and Eloise finds that like her, she watches for shooting stars, said to be ridden by unicorns. When a busker snatches the blacksmith's paper from her grasp, Eloise is at a loss to remember what was written, but the dying spinach in the vegetable patch points to the veracity of the words, telling of something happening at the next full moon. And just when the girls are beginning to trust each other and share what they know, Janie is adopted by a family on a distant farm. But the full moon approaches.
Brian has written an engrossing, multi layered story about Eloise, a character all readers will admire and love as she battles with her situation. The cold, loveless background bristles with injustice, and the magical turn of the story will further beguile readers' imaginations. What a cracker of a story. Teacher's notes are available. Themes: Family, Magic, Belonging, Orphanages, Abuse.
Fran Knight

The friendly games by Kaye Baillie

cover image

Illus. by Fiona Burrows. MidnightSun Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781925227642.
(Age: 5+) A motherless boy called John Wing was taken into a welcoming children's home where he had many other children to play with and everyone was invited to each other's birthday party. At eight he was adopted and missed the friends he had at the children's home. New to his school he checked out all the sports he could find, but instead of choosing one to learn, he found out about the Opening Ceremonies at the Olympic Games. He was enthralled, but could not understand why there was no big closing ceremony. He read all he could about the Olympic Games, especially when it happened to be in Melbourne in 1956. He loved watching the bunting and the lights, and loved the way ordinary people joined in, especially when taking in some of the athletes to their homes. John read all he could, even the articles about boycotting and fights between the athletes, and was concerned that this was what people would remember, not the friendliness of the games, which was the aim. So he wrote a letter. He heard nothing back from his letter writing, but at the end of the games he was amazed to see the athletes all together just as he had suggested, celebrating the closing of the Friendly Games.
A wonderful tribute to the power of just one person, The friendly games shows how one boy wrote a letter which made a significant change to the direction of the Olympic Games, and instead of the Melbourne Games being known for the politics which divided some teams, is known forever as the Friendly Games.
An author's note at the end of the story fills out the background on which this picture book is based, and gives more detail about John's life.
This book would be useful when talking about the Olympic Games, but the illustrations of Melbourne and the spirit which surrounded the city at that time may have been better served as photos. There are some apt touches, with John watching TV in a shop front, TV only just getting to Australia in that year, and the images in the streets of Melbourne. Themes: Olympic Games (Melbourne), The Friendly Games, Sport, Migration.
Fran Knight

Rules for being a girl by Candace Bushnell & Katie Cotugno

cover image

HarperCollins, 2020. ISBN: 9781529036084. 293pp.
(Age: 15+) Highly Commended. Marin & Chloe are friends who both have crushes on Mr Beckett (Bex), their hip, young English Teacher. Marin's boyfriend, Jacob, is the school Jock but she often stays late after school, working on the school newspaper with Bex. Marin aspires to a career in journalism at Brown University but after accepting a ride home via Bex's house, the plot quickly becomes a cautionary tale. Naively, Marin is certainly not prepared for what happens when Bex crosses the line.
The upside to Bex's unapologetic betrayal of trust, if there is one, is Marin's awakening to the feminist perspective. Marin, already critical of the gender inequities in the school dress code, identifies more gaps in resources and expectations between the two genders. Jacob struggles to support the 'new' Marin, who pens a cathartic editorial about the confusion and double standards experienced by young women, entitled "The Rules for Being a Girl".
"Don't be one of those girls who can't eat pizza. You're getting the milk shake too? Whoa. Have you gained weight? Don't get so skinny your curves disappear. Don't get so curvy you aren't skinny. Don't take up too much space. It's just about your health . . . ." (page 81)
When Marin confides in Chloe, she is jealous rather than supportive. Principal DioGuardi also accepts Bex's account. For much of the story, Marin turns to Gray, a boy who admired her editorial and joined the feminist book club, to navigate the sexist policies the students are subjected to. Despite his temporary triumph, Bex is angry that Marin would seek to harm his career by snitching. He sinks to new lows to hurt Marin for "breaking the rules". A true heroine, Marin overcomes the devastating setback and teaches her own lesson - one that will chasten both Mr Beckett and Principal DioGuardi.
An impressive snapshot of a typical High School culture, Bushnell and Cotugno have created a worthy role model and guide in Marin. Her journey and her pivotal "Rules for Being a Girl" editorial, should be mandatory reading for all teenage girls.
Deborah Robins

Peta Lyre's rating normal by Anna Whateley

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760525309. 237p.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Peta & Jeb have been friends since childhood. Now they both attend a Queensland technical college on the wrong side of the tracks. Peta has an Autism Spectrum disorder. Although high functioning, it takes only a few pages for the reader to appreciate the privilege of being inside this narrator's head. After certain events, Peta's thoughts and often the rote "rules to fit in", given to her by her therapist, provide detailed insight into living with invisible disabilities denoted by letters of the alphabet - ASD, ADHD etc.
Although it is the assumption, the students are not the problem. Like every teen, they flounder to work through their respective physical, cognitive, familial or social disadvantages with varied success. Peta lives with an understanding aunt as Jeb deals with an abusive father. Sam is the new girl. Her family is 'normal' but she has 'baggage' too. When the three new friends go on the school trip to the snow fields, sharing the dorms with private school students, the relationship between Peta and Samantha is explored. But Peta is not the only one who has communication problems. The author skates across many of the insecurities and identity forming rituals of adolescence faced by Sam, Jeb and the other students.  
The ski trip opportunity helps Peta and Jeb identify their life pathways but not before Jeb and Sam learn that Peta can take care of herself - that Peta's awkwardness does not make her needy or incapable. Peta proves that she can be more extraordinary without the rules; that her strengths, including her intense focus and honesty, are not deal breakers for everyone but her closest friends.
It may be confronting to witness Peta's reliance on medication and readers will commiserate with Peta's lows. Above all, we are exhilarated for her, when she demonstrates that she can be accomplished not only in spite of, but because of her idiosyncracies. Everyone, particularly teachers would be enriched by her inner story. Teacher's notes, a trailer and interview are available from the publisher.
Deborah Robins

Bin chicken by Kate and Jol Temple

cover image

Illus. by Ronojoy Ghosh. Scholastic, 2020. ISBN: 9781743830048.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. The term 'bin chicken' is new to me, but looking it up on google, I was amazed at how well grounded the term is. And the urbanisation of the Australian White Ibis is a problem almost Australia wide, beginning in the late 1970's.
As the ibis rummages through the waste we leave behind, a splendid opportunity is offered by the author to point out how much we throw away, and for classes to undertake some work about recycling.
But this book uses humour to tell its readers about the ibis and its strength, pushing aside the bullies and keeping on what she is doing. The verse story shows us the detractors: the sparrow, pigeon, seagull and crow, all picketing the ibis to stop giving birds a bad name. But Ibis carries on doing what she does: diving into trash cans, rummaging through dumpsters, swimming through rubbish, taking home odds and sods to its nest where her chicks are schooled into the life led by an urban iris.
The verse encourages readers to predict the rhyming words, and learn some of the stanzas, enabling them to read it along with the teacher, or read it for themselves. The lists of items found in the trash cans, dumpsters and lying around on the street will be added to by the readers, encouraging them to look out for waste left behind.
The digital illustrations add humour and background to the story and students will laugh at the antics of the other birds as they picket the ibis, call it names and deride its lifestyle. I love the rat, Ibis' only friend, as it supports the efforts of the ibis, keeping close by. Readers will love searching for Rat on each page, and laugh at the array of waste found by Ibis and Rat.
Despite all the rubbish thrown at her by other birds, the bullying by the quartet, Ibis comes out on top, building her nest, caring for her chicks, teaching them to scavenge as she does. They are survivors. Themes: Birds, Ibis, Rubbish, Scavenging, Waste, Verse, Read aloud.
Fran Knight

Ribbit, rabbit, robot by Victoria Mackinlay

cover image

Illus. by Sofya Karmazina. Omnibus (Scholastic) 2020. ISBN: 9781743834060.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Three friends, a rabbit, frog and a robot work in an antique store. When the frog pulls a book from a pile of books, a lamp falls on his head. Rub it, say the robot and the rabbit, and rub it, the frog does. Out of the lamp pops a genie with instructions about what to wish for, warning them not to be mean. Both the rabbit and the robot are quick to use their wishes, but the frog takes his magnifying glass to look closely at the fine print. Rabbit has wished for another rabbit while the robot has been given a robotic dog, but both are dissatisfied and want to grab the lamp for themselves. Mayhem follows as the three battle for the lamp, taking them across the sea in a canoe, over the fields in bicycles, then in tractors, until they ascend in hot air balloons. Each page sees another scramble of the words robot, rabbit and ribbit as the author delightfully plays with the readers. Children will laugh out loud at the variations of these words, wondering what will come next. And the luminous illustrations full of movement and detail will add to their enjoyment.
Finally the trio rockets into space with the lamp, until the frog, still intrigued by the words at the end of the scroll, uses a fishing line to grab the lamp from the robot.
His selflessness is rewarded while the selfishness of the rabbit and the robot see their wishes undone.
This is a wonderful play on words which will have children amused and entertained, wondering about the word variations. The illustrations are meant to be pored over, searching through a myriad of detail as the trio cavorts over water, seas, fields and space, while the fabulous antique shop is full of wonders. The strong message of being unselfish will resonate with the readers as they laugh with the mayhem caused by the greed of the rabbit and robot. Themes: Robots, Rabbits, Frogs, Selfishness, Genie, Wishes.
Fran Knight

Nali and friends: Bwindi the windy gorilla by Dan Sultan and Rhys Graham

cover image

Illus. by Tali Gal-on. Scholastic, 2020. ISBN: 9781743836378.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Melbourne performer Dan Sultan has joined Rhys Graham and artist Tali Gal-on to produce a great sing-along book about farts. But watch out it is catching!
Part way through her world-wide adventure, Nali meets Bwindi, a very windy gorilla. Nali and her family have settled for the night in a tree; mum and dad, great grandmother, Nali and her sister all tuck their heads under their wings to sleep but Nali is astonished to hear the loudest of noises. Flying down to the ground to investigate, she finds a baby gorilla, chewing on some leaves.
Nali is concerned and asks him about the noise she has heard. Bwindi reassures her that the noise was him, and when she again asks if his parents are concerned, finds that his parents often keep each other awake with their noises, as they have much larger bottoms than he.
They laugh and talk together until Bwindi comes to miss her family in the tree so flies up to be with them.
Dan Sultan's ARIA award winning album, Nali and friends, has an offshoot with this story of Bwindi, so well suited for classes and children to discuss their bottoms and why they make the noise they make.
Perfect for discussions about health and hygiene, but also about family and friendship. Bwindi the windy gorilla will make friends with all those children who read the book.
And join along with Dan as he sings the song on YouTube. Themes: Animals, Farting.
Fran Knight

Aurora burning by Amie Kaufman and Jay Kristoff

cover image

The Aurora Cycle book 2. Allen & Unwin 2020. ISBN: 9781760295745.
(Age: Teens) Highly recommended. Following Aurora rising Aurora Legion's Squad 312 is back trying the save the galaxy from being overtaken by an ancient hive-like alien. Led by the meticulous Tyler and grieving for Cat, the team is determined to find the black box from the space ship, Hadfield, where Aurora had been asleep for two centuries. Adventures abound as the group evades pursuers and meets Kal's long lost sister, a Syldrathi commander. Aurora is determined to learn how to master her powers and use herself as the Trigger for the weapon that the ancients have left.
Written in alternating chapters from the six team members, Kaufman and Kristoff do a sterling job of describing the feelings and skills of the main characters, who may appear to be stereotypes (Tyler, the buff blond leader, Kaliis, the pointy eared, very tall and handsome elf-like creature) but are people that the reader begins to know very well. Interspersed with some very comic dialogue, especially from Scarlett, the diplomat in the group, the novel bounds along with breathtaking speed and high octane action. There are ship heists, gun fights, space war and fight after fight, with enough clashes and skirmishes to satisfy an adventure junkie.
Short chapters with the name of the character narrating at the beginning of each also help to keep the reader engrossed. Then there is a totally compelling cliff-hanger of an ending that made me search to see if there was another book to come (there is, thankfully).
Kaufman and Kristoff have succeeded in writing a fantastic second book in the series. The Aurora Cycle books are sure to leap off the shelves, and the gorgeous cover on Aurora burning, featuring Kal, is another enticement for readers to pick up the book.
Pat Pledger