Reviews

Leave the world behind by Rumaan Alam

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN: 9781526633095.
(Age: Adult / Senior secondary) Highly recommended. Clay and Amanda and their two teenage children, Archie and Rose, head off for a much needed family holiday staying in a luxurious Airbnb far off the grid. It's just what they all need, comfortable, with an entertaining area, French doors to the deck, a swimming pool, spa bath, and forest scenery with turkeys and deer in the background. Then the next evening, whilst relaxing after a day spent at the beach, there is a knock at the door. A genteel black couple claim to be the owners of the house, returning back to their home because of a huge power outage across the east coast. Is what they say true?
From here, this highly original story spirals out beyond anything you might expect. I was gripped, reading each short chapter after the next. Not wanting to give away any plot surprises, I can only say that Rumaan Alam draws readers into an overwhelming sense of dread, in the beginning reminding me of the 2007 psychological thriller Funny games. However Alam's novel isn't that kind of sadistic horror; instead it cleverly shines a spotlight on ourselves, our class divisions, prejudices, stereotypes, self interest, dependence on technology, in fact the whole modern world; and asks of us, if faced with the end of the world as you know it how would you behave, what would you do?
Themes: Dystopia, Social commentary, Human condition, Ethics.
Helen Eddy

The unwilling twin by Freya Blackwood

cover image

Angus & Robertson, 2020. ISBN: 9781460757536.
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Jules does everything with her twin brother, George. They are identical twins, right down to the birthmark on each of their bottoms. They get up in the morning and practise their yoga together, they don their identical jumpsuits and eat breakfast together, then play together all day long. In summer they go to the beach, wearing their identical swimsuits, sunglasses and hats. They frolic on the sand, collect shells, look at the other bathers and get into the water, although George is not too keen on the waves.
Readers will by now be rolling about on the floor with helpless laughter at George's antics, paralleling those of Jules, but noticing that something is a little different. Kids of all ages will love seeing the humour behind Jules' assumption that she and George are identical, seeing George get up to the sort of things that pigs do well, but also going along with Jules as his playmate. But at the beach, George falls asleep, dreaming of lolling about in a bath of mud, while Jules builds a sand castle.
She imagines the two of them living in the castle, but when she calls out to George she cannot find him at all.
Pencil, watercolour and pastel were used by Freya Blackwood for her distinctive illustrations. The title and publications pages showcase framed photos of the pair from newborn, seeing Father Christmas, donning tutus for a performance and blowing candles out on their third birthday cake. Readers will get a thrill seeing Jules and George doing the same sort of things they have done and recognise stages in their lives that are similar. Blackwood's illustrations fill the pages with beautiful images of family life, culminating in the wonderful sweeping images of children at play at the beach. All the fun of the beach is shown: the long hot drive there, setting up a spot for the umbrella, chasing seagulls, collecting shells, eating an icecream, and playing in the water.
A small disagreement occurs when George wakes and want to play, but Jules is not too willing. But like all siblings, the disagreement is soon resolved and an icecream settles the day.
This charming tale of siblings, of identity, of getting along with others will find an instant audience, asking for it to be read out loud over and over, reprising trips they have had to the beach with their families, laughing at Blackwood's gentle humour.
Theme: Sibling rivalry, Twins, Identity, Beach, Family life, Humour.
Fran Knight

Grug and the Bushfire by Ted Prior

cover image

Simon & Schuster Australia, 2020. ISBN: 9781760858483.
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Grug, that strange little creature made from the top of a Burrawang tree, is back in another exciting and dangerous adventure. In his note at the beginning of the book, Ted tells the reader that his home on a 200-acre rural property was saved by the Rural Fire Service in a bushfire, but much of the surrounding forest was burnt. Because Grug lives underground he would have survived and in this story, Prior tells of that adventure.
In simple, easy to read aloud sentences the reader is taken through what happens when there is a bushfire and why it occurs. A delightful little Grug, with his brown and yellow grass body with a tuft on his head, sees that the grass around his home is very dry and brown and leaves were falling from the trees. Cara the snake tells him that the smoke he could see in the distance is a bushfire and that he would be safe underground in his home. Soon it was full of other creatures taking shelter, and they could hear a roar and smoke started to come in. When the fire had passed, they went outside to see the devastation that it had caused, animals' homes burnt, and food lost. Grug shares what he had stored and is very glad when the rain comes and begins to restore the earth.
Grug has been a favourite of children for many years, remembered fondly by my son and this one is sure to be read aloud to my little grandson. The important messages about looking after each other and sharing in times of adversity, as well as caring for the land, are ones for everyone. And beginning readers will enjoy the large black print and illustrations that complement the text.
A portion of the proceeds from the sale of this book will be donated to the Port Macquarie Koala Hospital.
Pat Pledger

Elizabella breaks a leg by Zoe Norton Lodge

cover image

Illus. by Georgia Norton Lodge. Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760652555.
(age: 9+) Recommended. The fourth in this new series by the Norton Lodge sisters will delight fans of this zany Year Four student. Elizabella goes to the theatre with her year four class and teacher, Mr Gobblefrump. She is with her friend Huck and they have left their parents home with Toddberry, Elizabella's brother. Huck and Elizabella are a bit off about his mother and Elizabella's dad dating, but Tod tells them to get over it. The play proves a turning point for Elizabella. She adores it and cannot stop talking about the magic she has witnessed on the stage. She approaches Mr Gobblefrump the next day about staging a play of their own. He consents but tells her it is very costly and unless it is free, cannot go ahead. A challenge has been issued. Meanwhile, Elizabella's best friend, Minnie keeps wanting her attention and finally blurts out that she is off to New York where her mother has secured a job. Elizabella's world comes crashing down.
Light hearted, fun from beginning to end, Elizabella is a bright vivacious girl with lots on her mind. From working out how to grease down her dreadlock so the people behind her can see the stage, to making an undie flag to run up the school flagpole, to getting her friend join her and not be sad about leaving, the situations are all close to home, things younger readers can relate to, involving family and friends, school life and family concerns. And all told with a large dollop of humour inspiring readers to seek out the other three stories and hope for number five.
Illustrations by younger sister, Georgia add another level of humour to the tale.
Themes: School, Drama, Family, Friends, Relationships.
Fran Knight

The great realisation by Tomos Roberts

cover image

Illus. by Nomoco.HarperCollins, 2020. ISBN: 9781460759806.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. An optimistic look at the follow on from the COVID-19 year that we have all had, is revealed as the author strives to help children learn from the effects of the virus which has swept the world. Some would love the world to go back to simpler times, and revisit times past where things always seem to be so much greener, and this author's attempts at encouraging children to see an alternative path are commendable.
A spoken word poet, film maker and performer, New Zealand born Roberts wrote his poem in response to the pandemic sweeping the world, worried that children would be affected with the negative avalanche surrounding us all.
His poem, viewed 60 million times on youTube, was an instant success and snapped up by HarperCollins who enlisted Japanese artist, Nomoco to apply her glorious watercolour images to the words. So the book has been published, ready for children to read and think about life after the pandemic. The book will encourage discussions around the post pandemic world, and what children think can be done better.
Prior to COVID-19, the world's people had become too neglectful of each other in their wasteful, instant lives, clicking on their phones for goods, and despite the cities growing bigger and some societies having access to all they could want, many people were just alone. When the virus hit, people were told to stay at home. And here, people reverted to the old ways: smiling, clapping for thank you, talking to each other, going for runs, leaving the car keys untouched.
A positive image is given of people keeping in touch, watering the garden, growing vegetables, dancing, singing and baking. The question at the end of the book 'so why did it take a virus to bring the people back together?'  will be one talked of in many classrooms, as children dream of a better tomorrow.
Theme: Pandemic, COVID 19, 2020, Fear, Hindsight.
Fran Knight

Rain before rainbow by Smriti Halls

cover image

Illus. by David Litchfield. Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781406382358.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. A girl and her dog sit rather pensively on the front cover, looking forward, seeing a newly formed rainbow peeping through the trees. Light shines around them urging the reader to open the book to see how the story unfolds. The title is repeated on page one, followed by 'clouds before storm' alerting the reader to a rhyming pattern that will entreat them, encouraging them to read on. The dog looks forward, the girl hesitatingly looks behind, but over the page they have a light to guide them as the words tell the reader the 'old day is done'. By now readers will be in tune with the direction the book is taking, that of reminding all readers that there is darkness before morning, and that they must look forward to a brighter day rather than hesitate in the gloom.
With mental health such an issue for adults and children alike, more books are being published which encourage a positive attitude amongst younger readers. This one with its double pages of luminous colours will intrigue readers as they follow the girl's journey from darkness to light, night to morning. The words remind us that there are mountains to cross and journeys to take, decisions to make, and sometimes the dark will be upsetting, with dragons to fight and worries to overcome, there are ways to get over these fears. They can seek out friend and pathways, journeys, maps, ropes to hold on to, and finally a new day will dawn that is full of light and promise. And all of this is brightly reflected in the accompanying colour filled illustrations.
The rhyming pattern will enthral readers as they predict what the rhyming word might be, ready to call out a rhyming word at the end of each page, learn some of the lines to call out when the book is read again. Read out loud or in small groups, the whole will encourage positive attitudes, allowing children to discuss some of their fears, and give them pathways to help themselves maintain hope. Teacher's notes are available.
Themes: Courage, Hope, Mental health, Depression, Friendship.
Fran Knight

Pandemic by Jackie French and Bruce Whatley

cover image

Scholastic, 2020. ISBN: 9781760976088.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Reflecting the year we have had it is fitting that a book be presented for younger readers to learn of a pandemic that happened in the past. Children can read and learn of the Spanish Flu which circled the world in much the same way as COVID19 has, but with bitter consequences because of the paucity of scientific knowledge and care.
Whatley's pen and wash illustrations show us a different time, with men returning to Australia from The Great War, bringing home this deadly virus. In quarantine himself Whatley resorted to a quick and available medium for his images: a ball point pen. Overlaid with sparse colour washes of mainly browns and greens, the images he developed have an appealing freshness, with sepia tones communicating times past.
Children will readily notice the similarities and differences in government and public responses to the virus. Seeing families remain behind closed doors, shutting their curtains to warn others not to approach, noting the widespread use of masks, closed shops and homes but equally noting the vastly different medical responses. They will be intrigued with the ambulance, the transport used by the children to ferry the food to their neighbours, the lack of plastic tubs and containers, and equally delighted with images of how children looked one hundred years ago. In French's story she draws on the efforts of her great grandmother, galvanising the children to supply food to those in need in their community. They picked the food from neglected gardens and trees, fed the lambs, collected eggs from chook houses, taking it back to her to cook into soups and food parcels, ready to be cycled out and left on front porches for those in quarantine.
Readers will marvel at the self sacrifice of these families one hundred years ago and be equally impressed with communities' responses to COVID 19, able to share stories of what happened in their neighbourhoods.
This beautiful book, extolling the positive community acton which happened during the Spanish Flu, will ignite readers' interest in keeping alive the neighbourliness which occurs during COVID 19, so reviving the feeling of friendliness needed when a whole country is in quarantine.
To learn more of the Spanish Flu in Australia see the National Museum of Australia's site.
Themes: Pandemic, Virus, World War One, Community, Neighbours, Sharing, COVID 19, Kindness.
Fran Knight

Fighting words by Kimberly Brubaker Bradley

cover image

Text Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781922330628.
(Ages: 14+ / Young Adult). Highly recommended. "Sometimes you've got a story you need to find the courage to tell." Based on author Bradley's personal experience Fighting words deals with child sexual abuse yet is so much more than that. It is about what comes after, and about survival. By the time the story begins the abuse is in the past and is mostly hinted at and not explicitly spelled out, except for on one page (pg. 130). Two sisters, 12 year old Della and 16 year old sister Suki are involved and must deal with all the emotions and damage from what has occurred. It is about getting help and making plans and being safe and finding people to trust. And it is about consent, about love and about the unshakeable bond between sisters.
The girls have fled their home and been taken into foster care. Della, who tells the story, has a tough outer shell and doesn't trust or need anyone but her sister. She also swears a lot (in the book actual swear words are replaced with the word 'snow'). Suki has always been the strong one, but she suddenly starts screaming in her sleep and becomes distant.
When Della starts at a new school she encounters a bully but also a chance to make friends. Her therapist gives her the tools to handle the bully by making a strong statement about consent and about adults needing to believe children when they share problems. For Della the hardest part of telling her story now is realising how much of it she didn't know about at the time. And she bravely decides it's her turn to be the strong one and to speak out about the terrible things that Suki endured.
This is the first young adult novel for Kimberly Brubaker Bradley. The story has some lows (including a suicide attempt) but maintains a strong thread of hope, humour and positivity. There are 14 discussion points in the back of the book which are wonderful ways to get teenagers talking about issues such as family, sacrifices, problem solving, power imbalances, consent, decision making and consequences. Teacher's notes are available.
Themes: Sexual abuse, Sisters, Suicide, Relationships, Emotions, Family.
Kylie Grant

Ernie's journey by David Woodland

cover image

Berbay Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9780648785149.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. The spotlight falls on the power of storytelling in this new book from Berbay which publishes 'clever books for curious kids'. Woodland, a debut author uses his considerable skills honed in the film and animation industries to produce a story which highlights the way in which the telling of stories can influence others. Eli loves listening to Uncle Ernie, especially his stories about his travels and adventures. He has been hang gliding over the Great Dismal Swamp, used a cactus mobile to cross the Gobi Desert, skated across Antarctica and now home, wearing his bed socks and glasses, tells his nephews and nieces about his adventures. Eli asks him about one particular adventure, that of helping the occyphants and so the story unfolds of how Uncle Ernie helped them stop floating in the air with a simple change to their diet. Eli then asks for a story he has not heard before, and Uncle Ernie tells him about the chameleon mice. Eli then responds telling his own story about his big adventure with a giant crab, and when the cousins question the truthfulness of the story, Uncle Ernie points out the two large crab claw scratches on Eli's shell.
Uncle Ernie then tells the children of the time he was in the cave with the snakes and spiders, where all you could do was run away.
Each story focusses on a different type of adventure: helping others, testing your endurance, being creative and knowing when to retreat.
Uncle Ernie gives Eli his golden compass with which to go on his own adventures, and so he does, following in Uncle Ernie's footsteps and seeing the stories for himself.
Children will envisage a future where he now rests in his bed socks and tells an appreciative audience of his adventures.
This delightful tale of the power of storytelling, of imagination and creativity will be a hit read aloud to younger children. They will delight in the unusual creatures and machines Uncle Ernie meets, the adventures he has, the problems he solves.
The curiously understated illustrations with whiffs of Shaun Tan, Steven Woolman and Paul O'Sullivan, are engrossing in their detail and array of creatures which kids will love finding. I loved the compass endpapers and the scary caves in which the snakes and spiders lived and so will the readers.
Find out more about David Woodland and his work on the author's site.
Themes: Courage, Storytelling, Adventure, Family.
Fran Knight

Dreams they forgot by Emma Ashmere

cover image

Wakefield Press, 2020. ISBN: 9781743057063.
(Age: Adult) Highly recommended. This is an exquisite collection of short stories. Many have a filmic quality as Ashmere introduces a scene and moves like a camera would, resting on an object or a person, and then revealing subtle nuances in gestures or words as we are led further in. The language has the expressiveness of poetry, creating pictures and interactions, leading into stories that leave us pondering long afterwards.
Several stories explore a woman's attraction to a brilliant other, the beautiful but troubled Aveline, or the confident Romaine, or the fascinating Louisa; the admirer herself, an observer somehow less worthy, a 'Lame Horse', or ill or poor and less gifted. There is a suppressed longing to escape from the mundane, to rebel and run free like Vevette and her wild friend Rae.
'Silent Partner' gives a voice to the women ignored in family trees and the records of ancestors and descendants: the so-called spinster Harriet has a loved partner Winifred, the disgraced divorcee still has children, and the present day narrator has a 'great friend' or 'life partner', relationships that are authentic and enduring.
There are also stories of historical fiction, of men scarred by war, drunken fathers, hardworn women and families struggling in poverty, stories imagined from intriguing glimpses of women's voices buried in the archives. The settings range from Australia to England, France, and Borneo, all 'a mixture of memory, imagination and experience' that draw us into scenes from people's lives.
There will be images and descriptions that will stay with you long afterwards, just as the cover photograph suggests thoughts and imaginings; the stories can be read and enjoyed time and again.
Themes: Women, Relationships, Longing, Outsiders, LGBQTI, Historical fiction.
Helen Eddy

Macca and Al, super pals by Matt Cosgrove

cover image

Scholastic Australia, 2020. ISBN: 9781760970246.
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Macca and Al, super pals is the latest Macca the Alpaca story in the series written for younger children. Author Matt Cosgrove has cleverly combined rhyme with bright and colourful illustrations to provide another amusing and entertaining read. Macca and best friend Al play super heroes all day and they have all the toys super heroes need. Macca though dreams of becoming a real super hero and he and Al set about creating costumes with a mask, cape and underwear. They give themselves cool names, Mighty Mac and Sensation-Al, and try hard to get super powers. They help their friends Slow Jo, Rhonda the anaconda, the yaks and Harmer the Llama out of some tricky situations in their super hero costumes. However they soon realise that all the friends worked as a team and are all super heroes every day.
Macca and Al, super pals will be another enjoyable read aloud for young children especially those who can relate to being super heroes. Themes: Alpacas, Super heroes, Dressing-up, Playing, Friendship, Helping.
Kathryn Beilby

Healing lives by Sue Williams

cover image

Pan Macmillan Australia, 2020. ISBN: 9781760982034.
(Age: Adult) Highly recommended. This is the story of two truly amazing women, Catherine Hamlin, a highly educated privileged woman from Sydney, Australia, and Mamitu Gashe, a poor illiterate girl from a remote village in Ethiopia, whose paths crossed when Catherine and her husband Reg, both surgeons and committed Christians, took up the challenge to establish a school for midwifery in Addis Ababa. It was there that Catherine and Reg first became aware of the shocking suffering of many young girls severely damaged after prolonged and tortuous childbirth, left with fistulas, holes worn in internal tissue leaving them uncontrollably leaking urine or faeces or both. It is a problem rarely seen now in the western world with its high levels of obstetric care, caesareans, and antibiotics, but in Africa and Ethiopia, it is a huge problem; the women, in constant pain, and ashamed, are outcasts from society. The Hamlins became determined to help.
At 16 years of age, Mamitu was left with horrific fistula injuries following a four day labour and a stillborn child. Her husband and friends carried her on a stretcher over 100 kilometres across mountains and gorges in the desperate search for help. It was the worst case the Hamlins had yet encountered but they embraced her as their daughter and determined to operate as many times as necessary to achieve a cure.
Readers cannot fail to be moved, reading of the suffering of the young Ethiopian women and of the care and love that the Hamlins brought in their dedication to medical intervention. But perhaps most inspiring of all is the story of Mamitu, reciprocating the love she received, determined to also help, becoming a cleaner, interpreter, nurse's aide and then assisting and ultimately performing her own surgery, continuing Catherine's legacy, all without ever having had any schooling.
The Catherine Hamlin Fistula Foundation has restored the health and dignity of over 60,000 women. This book is a wonderful testament to the kindness, determination and dedication of two outstanding women and the people who continue their work.
Helen Eddy

The Tree by Graeme Base

cover image

Puffin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760897048.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Enticing illustrations will draw readers into this latest offering by award winning Base (Animalia) and they will linger over its message of sharing and working together. A curly-haired cow with long horns and eyelashes and a cute little duck linger under a beautiful big tree. Cow looks up and sees mooberries while Duck looks amongst the roots and see mushquacks. Both are happy with the tree, Cow building herself a castle in its branches and pulling up the drawbridge, while Duck has an underground hideout with a secret entrance. However, when a storm bends the tree Cow and Duck notice each other and believe that their mooberries and mushquacks are under threat. Then another storm blows the tree over and Cow and Duck must cooperate to help a new tree grow.
Base's illustrations are delightful. Both Cow and Duck come alive with their individual characteristics. The tree is a character in itself and the details of the castle in its branches and the hideaway in its roots are amazing. The double page spread that shows the tree against a beautiful dark blue night sky, with Cow perched in his castle looking at the sunset, and Duck lounging in his deckchair underground is beautifully drawn and memorable. Other animals who live in the tree peep out through the leaves and scamper around and readers will enjoy finding and naming them.
The narrative reads aloud well and finally shows the futility of pulling up the drawbridge in Cow's case or hiding the entrance by Duck. When they have to grow another tree, readers will be happy to see that creatures can live along side each other, sharing and helping each out.
Pat Pledger

Jumbo the most famous elephant who ever lived by Alexandra Stewart

cover image

Illus. by Emily Sutton. Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN: 9781526608581.
Highly recommended. Many, many years ago, there was an elephant named Jumbo. His story is one that has been told thousands of times over the years, and has lead to major changes in the realm of animal welfare. In this book Alexandra Stewart tells us the most amazing story about Jumbo's life and trek from the Sahara all the way to this his final resting place in America's National History Museum.
I was really enthralled by this book and read it from front to back as soon as I got it. I have now read it to my children, family members and other staff at my school!
We learn about how, in the 1860s, an elephant was shipped, trained and shipped again across the world! How his life varied in the zoo and the circus and eventually how modern science has allowed us to learn many new things about the magnificent Jumbo. Alexandra Stewart also tell us about the people involved in Jumbo's life, especially Mr Scott an extra special keeper/handler in the elephant's life.
Woven in to the pages is also information about the London Zoo, the difference between Asian and African elephants, and the lasting effect of his legacy in today's animal welfare and conservation efforts.
Overall, this book is one of my favourites! The story is engaging and full of interest at every page turn. I loved learning about Jumbo and how he was looked after over 100 years ago.
I cannot leave this review without talking about the illustrations. Emily Sutton has really created something special. Every page is beautiful. Her use of watercolours with pencil outlines shows the animals' emotions and brings them to life! I particularly love the pages depicting the London Zoo and the final page of the elephants in the sanctuary.
5 out of 5 for this book, especially great for the animal lover in your life.
Lauren Fountain

Fox: A circle of life story by Isabel Thomas

cover image

Illus. by Daniel Egneus. Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN: 9781526600776.
(Age: 5+). Highly recommended. Fox is a thoughtfully written factual picture book. The story begins and ends with the reader being encouraged to look and listen closely. There is life stirring in the shadows. The journey of the fox searching for food to feed her young is written in short sharp sentences e.g. 'Rabbits nibble fresh green shoots. Then freeze. Ears stiffen. Noses twitch. Fox creeps, then leaps.' This simple text will appeal to younger readers but also encourage the reader to look carefully at the clever illustrations which further enhance the meaning of the story. It is evident that the author has studied foxes and knows their traits as she has described the movement of the adult fox and the way her cubs play beautifully. She has cleverly introduced the reader to the unfamiliar word of 'gekkering' which is to make a series of stuttering throaty vocalizations in the manner of foxes when encountering a rival. This story though is ultimately one about the circle of life. The adult fox dies on the road, the cubs find their way safely back to the den and the body of the fox decomposes in the way nature intends it to. The death of the fox is sensitively addressed and the author is quite honest in the description of what happens to the body. At the completion of the story are important facts about what happens when something dies. The illustrations by Daniel Egneus seamlessly complement the text.
Fox is perfect for reading aloud in the classroom or sharing at home. A welcome addition to both public and school libraries. Themes: Foxes, Life Cycle, Factual picture book
Kathryn Beilby