Reviews

A room made of leaves by Kate Grenville

cover image

Text Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781922330024.
(Age: secondary/adult) Highly recommended. Historical writing at its best, this tale of Australia's colonial experiences, told through an imagined voice, gives a background and authenticity to one of Australia's storehouse of overlooked women: Elizabeth Macarthur. In reality there is little known of her life, and Grenville has taken what has been written down, fleshing it out through her 'discovered' diaries written as an older woman, looking over her long and eventful life.
Her diary is a recreation of a time when marriage was an alternative to living as an ageing spinster relying on the charity of a brother or nephew's family. And Elizabeth made that choice, joining someone she did not know to go to Sydney Cove where he could see openings for advancement and wealth, as befitted his grand image of himself.
Their hasty marriage, saw Elizabeth questioning what she had married: a cold, calculating, quick tempered man, bent on climbing the ladder of opportunity via his contacts gained through his years of army service. To this end he accepted a position with the New South Wales Corp, traveling to Australia on the Neptune, one of the worst ships of the Second Fleet, where he argued with the captain of both the ship and the regiment.
Arguments continued as he built up grievances, culminating in a court case in London, where he spent four years, (1801-5) leaving Elizabeth with their newly acquired property at Paramatta. An argument with Bligh saw him sent to England for court martial in 1809, not returning until 1817.
Grenville shows us how Elizabeth's background and skills, developed while living with her grandfather on a sheep farm in Devon, enabled her to establish Elizabeth Farm as the mainstay of the Australian sheep and wool industry.
Colonial society is viewed through the eyes of this long suffering woman, transported to the other ends of the earth, saddled with a man determined to find fault, rubbing shoulders with Captain Tench, Governor Arthur Phillip, astronomer William Dawes, as well as the Aboriginal people of Sydney Cove. The diary is an expose of life at Sydney Cove, giving the reader an enticing look behind the scenes. Told by Elizabeth it gives insight into the restrictions on women's lives at the time and new insight into one of the unsung founders of Australia. Themes: Pioneers and pioneer life - New South Wales, Women in Australia - Social conditions, Australia - History -1788-1851, Married persons, Secrecy, Pioneers, Macarthur, Elizabeth, Marriage, Australian history, Biographical fiction, Macarthur, John, Australia, Sydney (NSW) - History, Convicts, Aboriginal resistance, Astronomy, William Dawes, Captain Tench, John Macarthur, Wool industry.
Fran Knight

We are wolves by Katrina Nannestad

cover image

ABC Books, 2020. ISBN: 9780733340888.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Liesl (aged 11), Otto (aged 7) and Mia (nearly 2) Wolf, are German children who must escape from their home as the Russians advance at the end of World War II. As patriotic Germans they have been taught to speak positively about Hitler and assume that his plans are good. When finally their father is co-opted as a soldier along with many of the remaining men of his East Prussian village at the final stages of the war they start to get glimpses that all is not well. The advance of the Russian Army means they must escape in haste, initially with their Mama, Opa and Oma. But after Oma and Opa choose to remain in a barn and following a mishap on a frozen lake, it is just the children left to survive, living with the hope that they will see their Mama again. Their survival as 'wild' children is phenomenal as they must make hard choices and choose alliances to enable them to keep going. Eventually they seek refuge in Lithuania but must shed all traces of their German history and identity and 'adopt' a new family existence. The love they have for each other and their ability to see joy amid the horror of their wild existence owes much to the simplicity of Mia and her naive view of the world. Otto barely has time to be a child and Liesl must act on behalf of her siblings in ways that reveal that she has been forced to grow up much too quickly. But will they ever see their old family again? Is there hope in the horrors of the aftermath of war or must they lose everything to stay alive?
This is a serious story, akin to Gleitzman's Once or Boyne's The Boy in Striped Pyjamas, written in a naive voice about the circumstances of war for children. Based on the truth of the stories of other 'Wolfskinder' of this time, the Wolf children's account is a reminder that victims of war are sometimes very young. Katrina Nannestad is known for her tales of quirky children in comedic circumstances, but this very dramatic tale is a step into a much more serious approach to story writing. But she still manages to exercise her light touch as she uses Mia's very unsophisticated approach to life to inject some moments of lightness into a story filled with pathos. This is a joy to read, but tears threaten to fall at various moments as the reader struggles with this small Wolf pack in their journey of survival. Older readers will also enjoy this book for its insights into the German experience at the conclusion of World War II.
Themes: World War II; Resilience; Children in War; Family; Hope; Survival.
Carolyn Hull

Catch me if I fall by Barry Jonsberg

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760877613.
(Age: 11+) Highly recommended. The reader is firstly introduced to the world of Ash and Aiden. Identical twins, they have promised their mother that they will look out for each other, no matter what. Thiers is a world of privilege and the author perceptively describes of lives of children with expectations of entitlement who live in an exclusive estate and attend a wealthy private school.
Through the dialogue in the story we learn this book is set in the future. Sydney is adjusting to the ravages of climate change and life is not as we currently know it in Australia. Food insecurity and social inequities are explored through the lens of privilege. The characters are richly drawn and the reader is led to believe Ash is be both selfish and spoiled. Aiden is portrayed as wise and compassionate as he acts as a buffer between Ash and the world.
On a school camp, described as a five star, politically correct and work health safety controlled experience, Aiden and Ash are involved in an unexpected accident that forever changes their lives. From here on the reader is challenged by ethical dilemmas. The reader is left to reflect on what it means to be human and where life begins. The ethical issues raised in this book are complex. The author has crafted a deceptively simple book that will lift the heart and expand the mind.
The teacher notes, available here, provide guidelines and links to resources that expertly guide and support the opportunities for learning this book evokes.
Themes: Relationships (family, friends), Artificial Intelligence, Ethics (climate change, sustainability).
Linda Guthrie

A time for mercy by John Grisham

cover image

Hodder & Stoughton, 2020. ISBN: 9781529342338.
(Age: Senior secondary/adult) Recommended. Small town Mississippi lawyer Jake Brigance is given a case no one else wants. Popular Deputy Stuart Kofer has been shot and killed. It's Jake's duty to defend an immature 16 year boy who has admitted to pulling the trigger.
The town of Clanton in Ford County Mississippi is not large, but it does have a sheriff with a number of deputies as well as a city police force. Surprisingly its sheriff, Ossie Walls is black. He like other elected officials including the judge is up for reelection in the coming year. Mississippi in America's deep south is church going and conservative, they have the death penalty and many believe the gas chamber is not used often enough.
Twice divorced Kofer has been living with Josie and her two teenaged kids for a number of months. She has a history; pregnant at 15, a few unhappy and dysfunctional relationships, a couple of drug convictions, some time in prison, her kids in care and a life, at times, of living out of her car. Josie jumped at the chance of some stability, a roof over her head and food on the table. Kofer seemed like a great choice. But Stuart had a dark side especially when drunk, which was becoming more frequent.
Opinion in the town, from law enforcement, the Kofer family and the God fearing community was that who ever shot Stuart Kofer should go to the gas chamber. Jake Brigance has been leaned on by Judge Omar Noose to be the state appointed attorney for young Drew Gamble. He is about to become the most unpopular guy in town.
The facts of the case seem straight forward, an open and shut case. But as Jake gets to know Josie Gamble and her son Drew and daughter Kiera, the sympathy he has with the family grows as does his concern for the well being of Drew. Drew, though 16 has not yet hit puberty. He is small thin and looks 12. After his arrest he is withdrawn and hardly seems aware of what he has done. He is locked in the Clanton jail, a hostile environment with no facilities for a juvenile especially one with significant trauma. Kiera on the other hand, though 14, is physically mature and attractive, though timid and inhibited.
Jake Brigance has the support of the law firm and a few stalwart friends, but there has been a loss of business and threats to his family for his defence of Drew Gamble. He successfully gets Drew out of jail for psychological assessment and counselling and is able to arrange for Josie and Kiera to be cared for by one of the local churches.
When the trial begins Jake proves to be a consummate court room performer. He is able to use the few assets the Gamble family situation provides with skill like a chess player and keeps facts from the prosecution until the trial.
Grisham has written many books, many of them court room dramas, but A Time For Mercy seems fresh, riveting and eminently readable. Politics, the legal system, "the South", prejudice, religion and the human condition all blend to make this novel a joy to read.
Themes: Crime, Court room, Lawyers, Murder, Mississippi, Death penalty.
Mark Knight

The ultimate animal alphabet book by Jennifer Cossins

cover image

Hachette, 2020. ISBN: 9780734420091.
(Age: All) Highly recommended. What a wonderful book to get lost in: full of interest, but entertaining, informative and enlightening, turning some of the accepted ideas about alphabet books on their head, upending the idea of animal names being strictly formulated, making each reader engage their thought processes as they read. Now why has she included the grey great kangaroo under G, not K, or why does the keel-billed toucan appear on the K page not the T. Questions are posed on every double page, each covered with a variety of splendidly illustrated birds and animals, some of which are accompanied by a witty bit of information.
I turned to R to look up my favourite animal, the rhinoceros, having just been to Monarto Zoo to view the rhino and its calf, but it was not to be found on the R page. I thought about its full name and turned to W to spy the white rhino at the bottom of the page, accompanied by its calf learning from the information given that it is the second largest land animal in the world, males weighing in at 3600 kilos.
Also on the W page, is the Wyandotte chicken, willie wagtail, weedy sea dragon, Wilson's bird of paradise, the white bellied sea eagle, wildebeast and a whistling heron. Each image will entertain younger readers as they pore over the illustrations making note of the intricate drawings, and take in the information given.     
In large format, the bright yellow cover is attractive and mesmerising, challenging the reader to identify the birds and animals shown on the front cover, daring them to open the book and find which page the animal appears on.
A lovely book to challenge little minds, impelling them to look more closely a the words used to describe the animal and reposition their own thoughts about an alphabet book and just how an alphabet book works.
Tasmanian author/illustrator Cossins is a CBCA award winner, and well known for her A-Z of endangered animals, as well as 101 collective nouns.
Themes: Animals, Birds, Alphabet, Words, STEM.
Fran Knight

Wombat by Philip Bunting

cover image

Omnibus, 2020. ISBN: 9781760972370.
(Age: 3 - adult) Highly recommended. What a wonderful book about wombats and all those things that the word can imply. Who'd have thought you'd find youngbat or oldbat or chit chat or thisbat or thatbat in a picture book about wombats, but Phil Bunting's highly original sense of humour and off the planet encouragement of interaction and play with his audience, young and old hits the spot again.
The pairing of each illustration with just one word magnifies the meaning of that word. Eyes will dart from the word and its half rhyme with wombat to the image before them. The dour look on the wombat's face, its browns and greys, simple arm movements, all add to the humour on each page. The eyes reflect the way the wombat is thinking, and children will love replicating the wombat on their own pages, seeing how they can make the animal come to life as Bunting does. A wonderful read aloud, kids will pester adults for a re-reading, marvelling at the rhyming of the words, the links between each of the wombats illustrated, the conclusion of two wombats coming together, while foraging the few words which tell of a wombat's life. The endpapers reprise the flowers found throughout the book, and Bunting even includes a laugh on the publication page.
Theme: Wombats, Humour, Rhyming.
Fran Knight

Take to the skies by Anh Do

cover image

Illus. by James Hart. Sky Dragon. Allen & Unwin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760876364.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. When her parents are killed in a house fire, from which she is pulled with scarring facial injuries and her brother left in a coma, Amber finds that she has new powers. The fire began with a purple ball of fire hurtling form the sky, burning the house to the ground. Always interested in insects and their habitat, she finds that she can to some extent, communicate with them, initially able to direct where they go, using simple mind messages. So she foils the bullies as they pour milk over her, directing a dragonfly to mess Trish's hair, resulting in a public down grading.
A well scripted story, Do has got this genre to a 't', resulting in a fast paced adventure story, full of interest and mayhem, with believable characters that readers can identify from their own family and school groups. Amber receives some stick from a trio of bullies because of how she looks and her unusual interests, but you know that they will get some sort of come-uppance by the end of the story. Justin who shares Amber's interest is a good sidekick, loyal and supportive when needed.
Anh Do is now seemingly churning out these series for the mid primary readership, full of recognisable characters, high adventure and pace, and illustrated by James Hart, adding a layer of excitement and wit to the story. The second in the series is 'coming soon' but readers will be able to turn to the other involving series penned by Do for Allen & Unwin: Wolf girl, Mythrix, and Eboy. Reading group notes are available.
Themes: Adventure, Fantasy.
Fran Knight

Through the night sky by Anita Ganeri

cover image

Illus. by Charlotte Pepper. Dorling Kindersley, 2020. ISBN: 9780241355459.
(Age: 8+). Highly recommended. Through The Night Sky is a stunningly presented non-fiction book which captures many and varied aspects of what happens in the night sky. It is described as "A collection of amazing adventures under the stars." The striking contents page is presented in a whimsical horizontal format across a double page. The headings are:
1. Night flight
2. Lighting the dark
3. Seeing with stars
4. A night of flowers
5. Heavenly lights
6. The moon
7. Into darkness
8. Happy New Year
9. Signs in the stars
10. A journey to Earth
11. A visitor from above
12. Eyes to the sky
13. Our base in space
14. Seeing the Solar System
Each topic has a double page spread with simple yet informative text and further explanations and labels when required. The book contains a wide range of topics including historical information and relevant and recent facts about space, technology and nature. For example there is information on comets, the planets in our solar system, meteor showers, eclipses, the moon, flowers at night and nocturnal animals. The identification of the more noticeable constellations in both the Northern and Southern Hemispheres are beautifully illustrated and will appeal to those young budding astronomers. There is a detailed index for a quick search of topics.
The illustrations by Charlotte Pepper seamlessly complement the text and are quite exquisite. Photographic images add to the enjoyment of the book.
Through The Night Sky
is perfect for sharing in the classroom or at home or browsing by an individual both young and old. It would make a very special gift. Themes: Nocturnal Animals, Planets, Moon, Stars, Time.
Kathryn Beilby

Dragon Mountain by Katie and Kevin Tsang

cover image

Simon & Schuster, 2020. ISBN: 9781471193071.
(Age: 8-10) Dragon Mountain is a simple but imaginative tale that could be useful for introducing younger children to the fantasy genre. The setting is a mountain in rural China in contemporary times. The formula is that of young heroes who are sent on a camp by their parents in order to develop personal strengths and correct certain individual weaknesses. Each child bonds with a dragon that is matched to that child's particular self. As a team which relies on togetherness, they go on a quest to save both the world of humans and the world of dragons. The book concludes with a cliff hanger and if children are interested they must wait for the next book in the series.
The human characters represent different but complementary strengths. None are fully developed to the extent that children could strongly relate to them but that may come with the second book in the proposed series. The dragons who are matched to each child have their own distinctive capacities and personalities.
The authors have been sensitive about responding to current concern about gender and cultural representation. They have therefore ensured that there is gender balance and also mixed cultural representation including a bi-racial child in the cast of characters. Because of this some young readers who may not have seen themselves cast in a storybook role may enjoy an identification with the characters.
Many wonderful books have been written about quests and dragons including Carole Wilkinson's Dragon keeper series which takes readers back to the time of the Chinese Han Dynasty and the Wings of Fire series by Tui T. Sutherland which has attracted many eager fans.
Dragon Mountain is an action packed read with a plot that proceeds at a cracking pace.
Suitable for 8-10 year olds.
Wendy Jeffrey

The relentless moon by Mary Robinette Kowal

cover image

Lady Astronaut book 3. Tor Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781250236968.
(Age: Adult - Senior secondary) Highly recommended. Award winning Mary Robinette Kowal returns with another Lady Astronaut, Nicole Wargin, in her alternate history about flight to the Moon. Following The calculating stars and The fated sky, Earth is facing problems with the Space program, with sabotage and demonstrations arguing against it. With her husband, the Governor of Kansas, she uses her intelligence and skills to try to keep the program going and is thrilled when she is chosen to make another trip to the Moon colony. However, she faces danger as things begin to go wrong and it is clear that someone from the crew and colony on the Moon wants to disrupt life there. Will she be able to survive and help save the program?
The story is narrated in Nicole's voice, and the reader can easily relate to what she is feeling and thinking and get to know the other characters that surround her. It was different to have an older woman, in her fifties, with arthritis in her feet and a difficulty with eating when under stress as the main character. Despite her health difficulties her will power, skill with piloting, and sheer intelligence for working out complex problems came across clearly.
The setting of the Moon base, the personalities of the people who inhabit it, and the science around living on the Moon, all are described in a credible way. Each chapter has a news story about disasters that are happening on Earth and they add to the suspense as the reader finds out how badly the Earth is suffering.
With a mystery to solve, some heart-wrenching moments, an alternate history that is fascinating, codes and ciphers and a heart-warming marriage, as well as themes of racism and feminism, The relentless moon is a wonderful read. The conclusion was wonderful and unexpected. And for those who are wondering about Elma, the heroine from the first two stories, there are hints about what happens to her.
This is a really good science fiction series, with The calculating stars winning the Hugo Award, Nebula Award and Locus Award in 2019. The relentless moon is as well researched and finely written and could well be a contender for more awards for Kowal.
Pat Pledger

Fly on the wall by Remy Lai

cover image

Walker Books 2020. ISBN: 9781760652654.
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Twelve year old Henry Khoo lives in Perth with his mother, grandmother (Popo), older sister Jie and dog, Maomi. His Dad works in Singapore and the family usually spends the school break there. When the family decide to stay in Australia for the break Henry decides he will secretly travel to his Dad's on his own. This is remarkable as not only has he never even caught a taxi on his own but Henry's mother, sister and grandma hover over everything he does. He is shy and quiet with a best friend, Pheebs, but she has become distant since an incident at her birthday party. As a distraction Henry secretly starts an online web comic at school called Fly on the Wall posting gossip, and hurtful observations about other students. It gets a lot of attention and he keeps posting cartoons even though he is terrified his secret will be revealed and he will be suspended. To boost his confidence he imagines himself as a character in a Wuxia drama his grandmother is so fond of. The disciple is faced with a number of trials where he follows the guidance of a wise mentor to defeat his enemies, face personal challenges and emerge having learned kindness and wisdom. As he embarks on his secret journey Henry faces many challenges, shows kindness and develops some insight, most noticeable in his sketches as his arch enemy, Tim Aditya, transforms from mouse to frog and finally a boy very like Henry. Told in the form of Henry's secret journal with sketches, there are engaging diagrams and comics scattered through the text and there is a second style that he learned at school which distinguishes his Fly on the Wall posts. A nice touch, when his notebook is missing, shows entries written on serviettes. He finds that it might be better to have a helicopter family rather than an indifferent one but the relationship he is seeking with his father still seems a bit elusive.
An attractive book for a difficult age group, funny, lightly told with no heavy moralising. Recommended for a wide range of readers from eight years, especially those from a non-English speaking background. Teacher's notes are available.
Themes: Friendship, Family, Adventure, Humour, Multicultural fiction, Illustrated novel.
Sue Speck

The thank-you present by Jane Marino

cover image

Illus. by Annie White. Smiling Mind 1. Penguin, 2020. ISBN: 9781761040054.
Subtitled A book about gratitude, this book is also the first in a five book series by the Australian mindfulness organisation Smiling Mind.
The story follows two best friends Evie and Lola who share a major love for many things including their birthday month July and opening presents!
With the help of Lola's Dad, the two girls look for ways to show their gratitude/thankfulness for each other's friendship. They aim to make the greatest presents ever, for the most amazing friend in the world.
Once they have made their respective gifts, both girls show worry and excitement. Will their friend like their gift? Will it show how they feel about their friend?
I liked the concept of this story (showing gratitude for people in your life) and thought that it was written in a way that young children could understand and relate too.
This book would be a great edition to a school/kindergarten library for use in lessons within the topic of kindness/gratitude or even for individual use when potential issues arise.
The back of the book also provides some extra activities and information for readers to create their own thank you presents, or letters. There is also information regarding a Smiling Mind meditation which is designed for children and young people. This is a great addition to the book and a nice introduction to the Smiling Mind app and general meditation.
Overall I liked the story and will be interested to read the other four in the series, and use them as part of our classroom curriculum resources.
Lauren Fountain

Our shadows by Gail Jones

cover image

Text Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781922330284.
Centred around three generations of Irish extraction and the gold mining town of Kalgoorlie first we meet poor families in Ireland, many of whom fled the potato famines of the 1850s, sailing to America and Australia in search of better lives. Paddy Hannan was one of those and it was he who stumbled upon the Kalgoorlie gold deposits, becoming wealthy, living every prospector's dream. Digging the wealth from the ground provided work for generations of miners in the hot, dusty outback town which has grown to have the biggest open cut goldmine, the Superpit. In 1977, when their mother died giving birth, baby Frances, and her sister Nell, 18 months, were sent to Kalgoorlie to be brought up by their grandparents, miner Fred, Else and their aunt Enid.
The fragmented narrative shifts between reflecting on the life of Paddy Hannan and the lives of the family, shifting between Fred and Else's lives, the girls' childhood memories and adult struggles. Reflecting on what is shared and what is suppressed and the damage done by greed, war, mining and emotional repression the author picks away at their lives sorting through seemingly trivial memories that pivot on significant moments in their lives. I tired of the constant analysis of the character's emotional states and questioned some of the feelings assigned to the historical figure of Paddy Hannan. I was ready for the book to end at page 227 when Part Two was introduced. While it was a nice addition and I felt the character of Val was beautifully drawn, it seemed to be there to fill the need for an indigenous voice.
Lovers of historical fiction and Gail Jones' other works will enjoy this book and it shines a light on Australia's biggest goldmining town.
Sue Speck

A deadly education by Naomi Novik

cover image

The Scholomance, book 1. Random House, 2020. ISBN: 9781529100860.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Easier to read than Uprooted and Spinning silver, which I loved, A deadly education is set in the Scholomance, a school for those with magic. El is a mouthy heroine whose magic is so strong that it could be disastrous for everyone. And Orion Lake is a young man whose whole purpose in life is saving people from the deadly creatures that haunt the school. When the two clash after Orion saves her life, secrets begin to show themselves, and El must find a way to stay alive and maybe save others at the school.
El is a grumpy, sarcastic heroine whose asides will have readers grinning, but at the same they will begin to relate to her as her life story gradually unfolds. Orion Lake too is a hero who is only appreciated for his magic powers and El is the first person who has seen him as lonely and needing real friends. El has always been aloof, but when the Scholomance is under threat she must find some allies and work with Orion to help defeat the monsters.
The descriptions of the life that the pupils must endure in the Scholomance are fascinating. Everyone needs mana (magic) to survive and there are unique ways of obtaining it, the dark magic is malia, and those who wield it to master spells pay for it later in life. Novik also explores the class system that operates in the school. There are privileged people who belong to enclaves, coming from rich and powerful families. Those who do not have these connections scurry around looking after them, in the hope that they will be accepted into an enclave after graduation.
Readers who enjoyed the Harry Potter books and the Magisterium series (Iron trial by Holly Black and Cassandra Clare) will be happy to move onto this series, as will those who liked Sorcery of thorns by Margaret Rogerson.
An eye-opening cliff-hanger conclusion will ensure that anyone who has read the first book will be eagerly waiting the next in the series.
Pat Pledger

We are all kind by P. Crumble and Jonathon Bentley

cover image

Scholastic, 2020. ISBN: 9781760972363.
Highly recommended. "I really really really . . . LOVE this beautiful book!" writes Magda Szubanski on the front cover and I really really really . . . think the same thing. I read it to my co-reviewers, a year 5 class, just to see if I was on track and yes, they agree.
Jonathon Bentley's illustrations delight the reader on the front cover and throughout. The smiles on the faces of the animals are full of interest, concern and suggest a team approach.
Each double page contains a 4 line verse beginning with repetition of "We are All KIND" with the second and fourth line rhyming. As each page is turned the same pattern and rhythm are repeated with a comforting poetic effect - delightful for the reader and delightful for the child.
Softly sketched and coloured illustrations of different animals appear on each page. The scenarios include lending a hand, the healing power of love, mending hurts, strangers becoming friends, hospitality, steadfastness, healing loneliness, sharing, inclusion and forgiveness. Larger themes about mutually caring for the earth and doing what is right as an individual in order to look after the group are the culmination of the book.
This book is worthy of multiple re-readings. It's so full of love and joy. I can see it as a home staple bed time story, a favourite in the Junior School library and on every discerning grandparents' shopping list. With values like this, presented by such an engaging author, read by a loving adult, the lucky child will be cocooned in kindness and motivated to do what is kind.
Wendy Jeffrey